Thread: syntax
View Single Post
  #8 (permalink)  
Old 10-Apr-2007, 07:56
Andrew Whitehead Andrew Whitehead is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Country: Yorkshire
Posts: 260
Current Location: Singapore
First Language: English
Member Type: English Teacher
Thanks: 0
Thanked 13 Times in 13 Posts
Andrew Whitehead is on a distinguished road
Default Re: syntax

Quote:
Originally Posted by Super Sonic View Post
Is this one the same as well: "c. I read the book in my room." ? It may mean that "I always read my book in my room" and that "I read my book in my room yesterday", right? The difference can only be understood by listening to(Is this preposition required here? ) how the word read is pronounced, I guess...?
"I read the book in my room" could mean:-
1) The book that I read is now in my room
2) When I read the book, I sat in my room to do it

The structure of the sentence makes it unclear, because 'in the room' has two nouns ('I' and 'the book') in front of it, so either 'I' or 'the book' could in the room.

What you are saying is true, in that it could mean 'I read the book in my room (all the time)' or 'I read the book in my room (in the past)', but the different pronunciation of 'read' would make the meaning clear to a listener.
Reply With Quote