View Single Post
  #4 (permalink)  
Old 10-Sep-2007, 15:41
engee30 engee30 is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Country: Poland
Posts: 975
Current Location: Swindon, England
First Language: Polish
Thanks: 5
Thanked 103 Times in 100 Posts
engee30 will become famous soon enoughengee30 will become famous soon enough
Wink Re: The sentences above/below are correct

Quote:
Originally Posted by Soup View Post
Take a look here also, above/below | Antimoon Forum
_________________


In the sentence (that is located) above <adverb>
In the above sentence <adjective> & <see note below>
The above sentence <adjective>

In the sentence (that is located) below <adverb>
In the below sentence <adjective>
The below sentence <adjective>

In short, all the combinations work except below + sentence. Below, unlike above, can't function as an adjective.

______________
Note, above can function as an adjective, but if it's a transformation or modification of in the sentence that is located above, wherein it functions as an adverb, then this phrase in the above sentence)--while often used--is awkward, but only from a strictly grammatical point of view. That is, people will say it and write it, but some, especially the most pedantic of speakers, will question its construct, because above is moved out of an adverbial position into an adjectival position:

Adverbial postion: In the sentence above...
Adjective position: In the above sentence...
So I think it's time to disprove the rule against using below as an adjective:
below. The Columbia Guide to Standard American English. 1993
Reply With Quote