View Single Post
  #2 (permalink)  
Old 19-Feb-2005, 09:06
Mister Micawber's Avatar
Mister Micawber Mister Micawber is offline
Key Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2004
Country: USA
Posts: 1,817
Current Location: Japan
First Language: English
Thanks: 0
Thanked 10 Times in 10 Posts
Mister Micawber is on a distinguished road
Default Re: i am not sure these reported speech rules work.please help!!

(1) The indirect form is fine, while past perfect is formally preferred by some strict grammarians, and the number of verbs in the dependent clause is irrelevant.

'The speaker was speaking and the audience was cheering.'
He said that the speaker had been speaking and the audience had been cheering.
He said that the speaker was speaking and the audience was cheering.

As long as there is no confusion about the time relationships, simple past is adequate and past perfect is overkill.

(2) Also wrong rule. Nothing to do with length of time.

"I lived in London for 2 years."
He said that he lived in London for 2 years.
He said that he had lived in London for 2 years.

Again, both reported speeches are fine, with the same caveat: as long as there is no confusion about the time relationships, simple past is adequate and past perfect is overkill.
Reply With Quote