View Single Post
  #11 (permalink)  
Old 02-Jul-2005, 11:55
M56
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: as much ... as ...

Quote:
Originally Posted by X Mode
If an adjective is not gradable, and someone uses it as a gradable adjective, I believe I'll notice it. In other words, I can separate language which does not sound good because it is not usual, and probably incorrect, and language which might seem to be "not okay" in a rather small "technical" way, but in reality really is - OKAY.

So it seems that although "unnecessary" is an ungradable adjective, it can be modified with an extreme adverb. However, I would not do the same, for example, with "foremost".

I can hear myself saying "that was completely unnecessary". - no problem. If one says there's something wrong with it, this, in my opinion, means that one learned English after having acquired it as a first language. One should trust that one speaks correctly. I'm not relearning anything, thank you - if you know what I mean. My language is correct.
<So it seems that although "unnecessary" is an ungradable adjective, it can be modified with an extreme adverb. However, I would not do the same, for example, with "foremost". >

"Foremost" is clearly ungradable. It means "preceding all
others"; "un/necessary" is not clearly ungradeable because it is an used in subjective evaluation. It has modality.
Reply With Quote