Printable View
Hello all,
Sorry for the topic name, but I still don't know which version is correct.
Question:
What is the problem?
Answer 1:
I tell you what the problem is. - I often hear this
Answer 2:
I tell you what's the problem. - I often hear this
Answer 3:
I tell you what is the problem. - I never hear this
Okay, my main question:
Are answer 1 and 2 correct?
Is answer 3 wrong?
Thank you!!
Cheers!
They are all wrong. "I will tell you what the problem is" is correct.Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightmare85
I can't see how you think that the third is wrong while the second is correct. A single apostrophe makes it grammatically incorrect, don't you think that this is a bit strange?
The first one is correct in the sense I assume you meant.
But the second and the third may be correct especially, one mimics a question which has just been asked and found it silly or annoying or something like that.
Thank you!
@bhaisahab:
Okay, maybe they said: "I'll tell you...".
However, I cannot guarantee this...
(It's not always easy to understand words when they are quickly spoken.)
@euncu:
I will tell you why.
This reminds me of this:
Can you not help me? - correct
Can't you help me? - correct
Cannot you help me? - wrong!
And that's why I thought it could be the same with the "What's" instead of "What is".
Okay, I guess these are two completely different cases, but well...
Cheers!
"Can't you" is a contraction of "can you not" not "cannot you".Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightmare85
Sometimes we don't hear them, but we know they are there.;-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightmare85
Hmm I guess
"I'll tell you what's good" and "He knows what's good" is right, because "is" and "good" are linked, aren't they?
Probably the same as "is going on".
I know what is going on - this is definitely right, I've learned this here :up:
Not easy guys, not easy... :-?
Cheers!
No one said it was easy, "no pain, no gain".;-)Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightmare85