Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Nordic Bill Thanks for clearing this one up for me. As I mentioned, the "are" option sounded monumentally incorrect. |
You're welcome.
With
There-initial constructs - also known as
existential there - the
true subject comes after the verb, like this,
Subject: There is
a book on the table.
Subject:
A book is on the table.
Subject-Verb agreement is based on proximity. That is,
EX: There
are books as well as paper on the table.
EX: There
is a book and paper on the table.
'are' agrees in number with 'books', and 'is' agrees in number with 'a book'. Those nouns are closer to the verb than 'a paper' and 'paper'.
With 'and', the trick is to make sure the nouns agree in number, and if not, the plural noun comes before the singular noun, like this,
[1] There are
pencils and
a book -(they are)- on the table.
[2]
?There is
a book and
pencils on the table. (
?=awkward)
'are', in [1], agrees in number with the noun 'pencils' as well as with the combined set 'pencils and a book' - they. In [2], 'is' agrees in number with the singular noun 'a book'. 'is' can be stretched to include the set 'a book and pencils; i.e., this set, but . . . that's stretching it.
Hope that helped.