
Originally Posted by
Raymott
You need to be clear about whether you are using "then" as an adverb of time ('after that', 'at that time'), or what might be called an adverb of consequence. The sentences require an adverb of time.
Sentences 1, 3, 4 use 'then' correctly (albeit that they are not very elegant.)
Sentence 2 uses 'then' as an adverb of consequence. As such, it doesn't make sense. If you removed the commas, it would be an adverb of time, as in the other sentences.
'Then' as an adverb of consequence - nothing to do with time:
"Well, if that's how you feel, then I won't go with you."
"The price rose from $100 to $200. This, then, was a rise of 100%.
"What does this sentence mean, then?"