I have a question about collective noun and would you check this sentence?
'Now a team of ten internationally known architects have submitted designs ans strategies for creating a metropolitan area that will be known as "Grand Paris".
As far as I know, team is collective noun and can be both of singular and plural. I think, by the structure, subject of the sentence is 'a team' which should be followed by 'has' not 'have'. I've asked 2 native speakers and both said 'have' sounds better here but none gave an answer to 'why', which I need to know.
Can you give me clear answer to that ?
***** NOT A TEACHER *****
(1) I cannot give you a clear answer, but I can you an answer.
(2) I believe that you are 100% correct (at least in terms of American English).
(3) The team has submitted plans. I assume that the team submitted the plans
as a group. That is, the 10 architects did not individually submit 10 plans. The
team submitted plans that represented the group's consensus.
(4) Here is an example that many American teachers give:
The jury has announced its decision. The jury have now returned to their
respective homes.
The 'team' consists of ten different architects who work independently of each other and submitted their design proposals on an individual basis rather than working together as a team effort. Presumably, the best design proposal would be adopted and the successful architect gets appointed for the job. When we refer to a group of individuals working separately, it is more appropriate to use the plural.
not a teacher
Last edited by tedtmc; 04-Sep-2011 at 01:02.
Now, I see.
Thanks a lot, both of you 'not teachers'!