12Likes -
1 Post By hoangkha -
2 Post By 5jj -
1 Post By hoangkha -
2 Post By 5jj -
3 Post By Tdol -
1 Post By emsr2d2 -
1 Post By 5jj -
1 Post By emsr2d2
-
I have a question.Help me please.
- His son and his dog,................. got lost yesterday, have been found by the police.
I make up this sentence to illustrate my question that
What relative pronoun is used in the above sentence?
Thanks in advance.
-
Re: I have a question.Help me please.
We'd use 'who'. The boy is rather more significant than the dog.
In real life, we'd be more likely to say, "His son, who got lost while walking his dog yesterday, has been found. He and the dog are alive and well'"
-
Re: I have a question.Help me please.

Originally Posted by
fivejedjon
We'd use 'who'. The boy is rather more significant than the dog.
In real life, we'd be more likely to say, "His son, who got lost while walking his dog yesterday, has been found. He and the dog are alive and well'"
Dear teacher!
Thanks a lot!
But I am taught that
- In defining relative clause, THAT is used when the antecedent includes people and things.
Ex:- The boy and his dog THAT got lost yesterday has been found.
- In non-defining relative clause, THAT isn't used.
Therefore, I am wondering what relative pronoun is used when the antecedent includes people and things in non-defining relative clause.
Best regards!
-
Re: I have a question.Help me please.
In your sentence, we have a non-defining relative clause, so 'that' is not an option. We therefore tend to avoid relative clauses in which the relative pronoun refers to both people and things, as I suggested in my first response.
Last edited by 5jj; 08-Oct-2011 at 10:28.
Reason: Typo, again!
-
Re: I have a question.Help me please.
Also, we can use who for animals like pets- if I were talking about my dog, I could say My dog, who went missing yesterday, was found this morning.
-
Re: I have a question.Help me please.
To avoid using a relative pronoun in sentences of this kind , I use a participle phrase.
- His son and his dog, getting lost yesterday, have been found by the police.
Is it possiple, teachers?
-
Re: I have a question.Help me please.

Originally Posted by
hoangkha
To avoid using a relative pronoun in sentences of this kind , I use a participle phrase.
- His son and his dog, getting lost yesterday, have been found by the police.
Is it possiple, teachers?
No, that's not natural at all.
His son and his dog, [both] lost since yesterday, have been found by police.
His son and his dog have been found by police, having been lost yesterday.
-
Re: I have a question.Help me please.

Originally Posted by
emsr2d2
His son and his dog have been found by police, having been lost yesterday.
I'd use 'got' rather than 'lost' there. As it stands, it seems to me as if someone mislaid them.
-
Re: I have a question.Help me please.

Originally Posted by
fivejedjon
I'd use 'got' rather than 'lost' there. As it stands, it seems to me as if someone mislaid them.
I wasn't quite sure if the son and the dog "got lost" (lost their way) or were lost by someone else!
If they lost their way, then I agree with you that "having got lost yesterday" would be better.
Similar Threads
-
By pussycat0121a in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 5
Last Post: 20-Sep-2011, 09:04
-
By JustAlilBit in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 9
Last Post: 19-May-2011, 22:04
-
By richuk in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 4
Last Post: 13-Apr-2010, 12:59
-
By Unregistered in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 04-Jun-2008, 12:12
-
By Phoenix Wu in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 13
Last Post: 10-May-2008, 07:45
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1