register for/with

[rainous]

It didn't register with me then.

It didn't register for me then.

Hi,

Do they mean the same or is one simply incorrect while the other one is good?

[Gillnetter]

It didn't register with me then. At that time I was not aware of what was happening.

It didn't register for me then. A machine perhaps, failed in it's function to register something. A gasoline pump should register the number of gallons of fuel it delivers. If it did not register the fuel last week, you could say that it didn't register for me then.

Hi,

Do they mean the same or is one simply incorrect while the other one is good?

Gil