Please need help with a sentence explanation

[learning54]

Hi teachers,

Could 'b' be a good explantion to 'a'?
a) You aren't wearing a tie.
b) You haven’t on a tie.

Thanks in advance

[5jj]

No. 'You haven't (got) a tie on'. It's not really an explanation of a; it's simply a different way of conveying the message.

[learning54]

No. 'You haven't (got) a tie on'. It's not really an explanation of a; it's simply a different way of conveying the message.

Hi,
Thank for your reply.

Is this a wrong way to convey the message?
a) You haven’t on a tie.
Should it be?
b) You haven't (got) a tie on.

Or are both of them correct?

[5jj]

Is this a wrong way to convey the message?...a) You haven’t on a tie. Yes
Should it be? ...b) You haven't (got) a tie on. ...Yes.
Or are both of them correct?...No

5

[learning54]

Hi,
Thanks once again.
So then, it is also wrong to say:
She has on a bikini.
I should say, 'She has a bikini on'.
Could you tell me why 'on' can't be after has / have?
But a good way to convey 'wear / wearing' is to say 'have on', isn't it?