in the second week

1. Can you tell me the tutorial day in the second week of May?

2. Can you tell me the tutorial day on the second week of May?

3. Can you tell me the tutorial day within the second week of May?
************************************************** ******

I would say #1 and #3 are correct with the same meaning. And, #2 is wrong.

Am I right?


Thank you,

Only the first sounds natural to me.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 5jj

Only the first sounds natural to me.

---

Dear 5jj,

Does it mean besides the proper English usages written in the grammar book, natural expression does play an important role in spoken and written English?
That why we don't pick #3 is the best answer even it's correct in usage.
Am I right?

Thank you.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Ju

That why we don't pick #3 is the best answer even it's correct in usage.

---

It isn't correct.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by 5jj

It isn't correct.

---

Dear 5jj,

Thank you for your reply.
Do you mean my understanding as follow is not correct or the sentence #3 in not correct?

""Does it mean besides the proper English usages written in the grammar book, natural expression does play an important role in spoken and written English?
That why we don't pick #3 is the best answer even it's correct in usage.""

Thank you.

Sentence #3 is not correct.