- 4 Post By 5jj
who were creating/commas
1-Three men were arrested in our small town last week who were creating a drunken disturbance.
2-Three men were arrested in our small town last week, who were creating a drunken disturbance.
Let us assume that those three men were the only ones arrested last week in our town. I suppose technically it would be preferable to use "2", as the clause in it is non-restrictive. But is the sentence natural? Would you say the sentence with a pause where there is a comma? And could not one use "1" instead of "2"?
Which of the these two is correct:
3-They arrested Jack Smith last week who is the mayor's son.
4-They arrested Jack Smith last week, who is the mayor's son.
Last edited by navi tasan; 03-Mar-2013 at 06:08.
Re: who were creating/commas
None of the sentences is very natural. Try to keep the relative pronoun as close to its antecedent as possible:
Last week, three men who were creating a drunken disturbance were arrested in our small town.
It's up to the speaker/writer to decide whether a restrictive or non-restrictive clause is appropriate.
In your other example, only a non-restrictive clause is appropriate:
Last week, they arrested Jack Smith, who is the mayor's son.
Context is important. Please provide enough for us to be able to deal effectively with your question.
Your thread title should include all or part of the word/phrase being discussed.
If you just want to know the meaning of a word, try OneLook Dictionary Search first.
By riquecohen in forum Support Area
Last Post: 08-Apr-2011, 11:17
By rasmer in forum Teaching English
Last Post: 26-Nov-2010, 06:21
By jctgf in forum Ask a Teacher
Last Post: 24-Aug-2008, 03:04
By new2grammar in forum Ask a Teacher
Last Post: 04-Jul-2008, 20:20
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO