Forum newsfeeds
Forum Newsfeeds


Sites for Teachers

Sites for Teachers


Go Back   UsingEnglish.com ESL Forum > Learning English > Ask a Teacher

Notices

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21 (permalink)  
Old 12-Dec-2003, 20:27
Editor, UsingEnglish.com
 
Join Date: Nov 2002
Country: UK
Posts: 25,671
Current Location: Phnom Penh
First Language: English
Member Type: English Teacher
Thanks: 6
Thanked 543 Times in 478 Posts
Tdol has disabled reputation
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by shun
I want to make clear this: Simple Past also denotes something complete, why it isn't past aspect?


Also, adverbials like these days, these weeks, these years, can work alone, dispensing with preposition. :o
The past does have aspects- the past progressive, for instance. The past tense simple is more about locating something in time, than trying to show it's completion or not. I can see your point and it's tricky to give a complete answer. The past simple is complete, but I would say the past progressive (incomplete) and the past perfect (complete) are the real aspects. The latter is used to emphasise completion at a particular point in the past. The past simple isn'y- it could denote a habit.
Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
  #22 (permalink)  
Old 13-Dec-2003, 01:23
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,997
Current Location: China
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 0
Thanked 54 Times in 53 Posts
Casiopea will become famous soon enough
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by tdol
Quote:
Originally Posted by shun
I want to make clear this: Simple Past also denotes something complete, why it isn't past aspect?


Also, adverbials like these days, these weeks, these years, can work alone, dispensing with preposition. :o
The past does have aspects- the past progressive, for instance. The past tense simple is more about locating something in time, than trying to show it's completion or not. I can see your point and it's tricky to give a complete answer. The past simple is complete, but I would say the past progressive (incomplete) and the past perfect (complete) are the real aspects. The latter is used to emphasise completion at a particular point in the past. The past simple isn'y- it could denote a habit.
The term 'complete' is used in reference to two events. One event completes the other; this is not to say that one or both events are finished (completed). There are two meaning here. Shun is under the assumption that 'complete' refers to the actual meaning of the verb:

I was skiing in Banff when I saw the yeti.

The events of skiing and seeing are finished. "I was skiing" can stand alone without the help of "when I saw the yeti."

Compare:

I had eaten before she arrived.

The events of eating and arriving are finished; 'I had eaten' cannot stand alone. It needs to pass its meaning onward. It's completed by 'she arrived'.

:D
Reply With Quote
  #23 (permalink)  
Old 13-Dec-2003, 08:58
RonBee's Avatar
Moderator
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Country: USA
Posts: 13,775
Current Location: North Carolina
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 77
Thanked 997 Times in 883 Posts
RonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to behold
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Casiopea
The term 'complete' is used in reference to two events. One event completes the other; this is not to say that one or both events are finished (completed). There are two meaning here. Shun is under the assumption that 'complete' refers to the actual meaning of the verb:

I was skiing in Banff when I saw the yeti.

The events of skiing and seeing are finished. "I was skiing" can stand alone without the help of "when I saw the yeti."

Compare:

I had eaten before she arrived.

The events of eating and arriving are finished; 'I had eaten' cannot stand alone. It needs to pass its meaning onward. It's completed by 'she arrived'.

:D
That's the best explanation I've seen.

:)
__________________
~R
Reply With Quote
  #24 (permalink)  
Old 13-Dec-2003, 09:46
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,997
Current Location: China
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 0
Thanked 54 Times in 53 Posts
Casiopea will become famous soon enough
Default

Thank you

Shun's next question will be something like this,

Q: What completes "I have eaten"? :D
Reply With Quote
  #25 (permalink)  
Old 13-Dec-2003, 15:47
RonBee's Avatar
Moderator
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Country: USA
Posts: 13,775
Current Location: North Carolina
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 77
Thanked 997 Times in 883 Posts
RonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to behold
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Casiopea
Shun's next question will be something like this,

Q: What completes "I have eaten"? :D
(Ron raises his hand and waves it wildly about.) Teacher, I know that one. That is complete. "I have eaten" needs nothing to complete it, because it denotes a finished action. (It's present perfect.) However, "I had eaten" awaits something to give it completion, perhaps only one additional word, thus: "I had eaten already."

How did I do?

:D
Reply With Quote
  #26 (permalink)  
Old 13-Dec-2003, 23:21
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,997
Current Location: China
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 0
Thanked 54 Times in 53 Posts
Casiopea will become famous soon enough
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by RonBee
Quote:
Originally Posted by Casiopea
Shun's next question will be something like this,

Q: What completes "I have eaten"? :D
(Ron raises his hand and waves it wildly about.) Teacher, I know that one. That is complete. "I have eaten" needs nothing to complete it, because it denotes a finished action. (It's present perfect.) However, "I had eaten" awaits something to give it completion, perhaps only one additional word, thus: "I had eaten already."

How did I do?

:D
You're a very good student, RonBee. :D

Now let's test your answer:

I have lived here for six years.

What completes 'I have lived'?

:D
Reply With Quote
  #27 (permalink)  
Old 14-Dec-2003, 02:52
RonBee's Avatar
Moderator
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Country: USA
Posts: 13,775
Current Location: North Carolina
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 77
Thanked 997 Times in 883 Posts
RonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to behold
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Casiopea
Quote:
Originally Posted by RonBee
Quote:
Originally Posted by Casiopea
Shun's next question will be something like this,

Q: What completes "I have eaten"? :D
(Ron raises his hand and waves it wildly about.) Teacher, I know that one. That is complete. "I have eaten" needs nothing to complete it, because it denotes a finished action. (It's present perfect.) However, "I had eaten" awaits something to give it completion, perhaps only one additional word, thus: "I had eaten already."

How did I do?

:D
You're a very good student, RonBee. :D

Now let's test your answer:

I have lived here for six years.

What completes 'I have lived'?

:D
"I have lived" is complete in itself. Example:
  • I have lived. I have died. I have laughed. I have cried.

:D
__________________
~R
Reply With Quote
  #28 (permalink)  
Old 14-Dec-2003, 10:59
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,997
Current Location: China
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 0
Thanked 54 Times in 53 Posts
Casiopea will become famous soon enough
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by RonBee
"I have lived" is complete in itself. Example:
  • I have lived. I have died. I have laughed. I have cried.

:D
Well now, you see, that's Shun's argument right there. If "I have lived" is complete (with)in itself, then what differentiates the Present Perfect from, say, the Simple tenses "I live" and "I lived"?

Thing is, it's not that the action has finished per se; rather, it's that the Present completes the Past, or the Past is completed by the Present:

"I have lived...(up until now)".

Implied "up until now", often omitted, ends the cycle. In other words, the

Present perfect expresses a cylce that starts in the Past and ends now in the Present. The Present completes the Past.

:D

What do you think? That is, can you think of any examples that contradict this?

:D
Reply With Quote
  #29 (permalink)  
Old 14-Dec-2003, 18:36
RonBee's Avatar
Moderator
 
Join Date: Feb 2003
Country: USA
Posts: 13,775
Current Location: North Carolina
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 77
Thanked 997 Times in 883 Posts
RonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to beholdRonBee is a splendid one to behold
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Casiopea
Quote:
Originally Posted by RonBee
"I have lived" is complete in itself. Example:
  • I have lived. I have died. I have laughed. I have cried.

:D
Well now, you see, that's Shun's argument right there. If "I have lived" is complete (with)in itself, then what differentiates the Present Perfect from, say, the Simple tenses "I live" and "I lived"?

Thing is, it's not that the action has finished per se; rather, it's that the Present completes the Past, or the Past is completed by the Present:

"I have lived...(up until now)".

Implied "up until now", often omitted, ends the cycle. In other words, the

Present perfect expresses a cylce that starts in the Past and ends now in the Present. The Present completes the Past.

:D

What do you think? That is, can you think of any examples that contradict this?

:D
The trouble with Shun's argument is that "I have lived" only works as a complete statement if I am dead. As a practical matter however, it doesn't work very well, because dead people rarely join in any conversations about grammar or anything else.

:wink:

I seem to have a knack for finding instances in which "impossible" statements are indeed possible. I apologize for that, but I think that does have practical value (in discussions of grammar if nowhere else).

It keeps you guys on your toes maybe, huh?

:wink:
__________________
~R
Reply With Quote
  #30 (permalink)  
Old 15-Dec-2003, 08:34
Casiopea's Avatar
VIP Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Country: Canada
Posts: 12,997
Current Location: China
First Language: English
Member Type: Other
Thanks: 0
Thanked 54 Times in 53 Posts
Casiopea will become famous soon enough
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by RonBee
The trouble with Shun's argument is that "I have lived" only works as a complete statement if I am dead. As a practical matter however, it doesn't work very well, because dead people rarely join in any conversations about grammar or anything else.
OK, then what about "I have lived in this house all of my life and I still live there now".

:D
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Tags
these, days, since

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
go for days Anonymous Ask a Teacher 2 24-Jul-2004 16:31
twelve days of the Christmas2 Anonymous Ask a Teacher 1 28-Jun-2004 16:28
the twelve days of Christmas Anonymous Ask a Teacher 3 28-Jun-2004 05:00
days a week in school for kindergarten/reception? Anonymous Ask a Teacher 1 13-Oct-2003 22:29


New To Site? Need Help?

All times are GMT. The time now is 03:24.


vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.2.0
Copyright © 2002 - 2008 UsingEnglish.com