-
Simple past and Past Perfect
I have two sentences:
He locked the door.
He went out for dinner.
Which tense we should use to connect them?
He locked the door and went out for dinner
Or: He had locked the door before going out for dinner.
Tell me which one is better? and the meaning of each one?
Tks
-
Neither one is necessarily better, but we would normally use simple past there. There is, absent context, no reason to use past perfect there.
:)
-
"Neither one is necessarily better." I haven't caught your idea
I will put my sentence in a situation like that: My house has been stolen and I want to insist to everybody that I locked the door before going out. Whether I should use the past perfect tense?
" I had locked the door before going out for dinner"
:)
Oh, by the way, what is an absent context?
-
How about this.
He locked the door before (he) went out for dinner.
Sounds more natural.
-

Originally Posted by
moonlite How about this.
He locked the door before (he) went out for dinner.
Sounds more natural.
Hi,
As I know, "before" is a prep and be followed by a noun or a gerund. So I don't think we should omit the subject (He). How about you?
-
I am no teacher. But what you say sounds ok to me. However, in general conversations, that sentence is often heard.
-
I agree with Solace- it should be 'before going' or 'before he went'.
-

Originally Posted by
solace "Neither one is necessarily better." I haven't caught your idea
I will put my sentence in a situation like that: My house has been stolen and I want to insist to everybody that I locked the door before going out. Whether I should use the past perfect tense?
" I had locked the door before going out for dinner"
:)
Oh, by the way, what is an absent context?
If I say "Neither one is necessarily better" then I mean that there is no reason to believe that one is better than the other.
In your example I would use the simple past. It is not necessary to use the past perfect. (I assume that you meant that your house had been burgled.)
Context is the surrounding sentences--the sentences that come before and after a sentence.
:)
-
Now, I do understand. Thanks :)
Another question: Which cases should we use past perfect tense?
-

Originally Posted by
moonlite I am no teacher. But what you say sounds ok to me. However, in general conversations, that sentence is often heard.
Hi,
If you say so, everybody can understand you. However I think it is not a standard English.
Anyway, such utterance will be accepted in verbal communication:)
Similar Threads
-
By Anonymous in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 05-Oct-2004, 14:27
-
By ripley in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 7
Last Post: 26-Sep-2004, 14:16
-
By shun in forum Teaching English
Replies: 143
Last Post: 09-Nov-2003, 00:56
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1