I am learning Ancient Greek, Classical Latin and Modern Hebrew and sometimes have difficulty with the English Perfect. In A. Greek the Perfect can have a current state i.e. He has died, means He has died and is now in a state of dead. Whereas the A. Greek aorist is - He died and that means one event and it is over with, the person died. With the English perfect, does it have a current state, i.e. he has died (20 years ago) and is now in a state of being dead OR does it have an A. Greek aorist type meaning where he died back then, and it is over with, it's a once off event with no continuing state.
Hello G., welcome to Using English!
The Greek aorist is closer to the English simple past tense than to the English present perfect.
On the whole, the English simple past expresses an event that is complete:
1. I bought a pair of trousers yesterday.
2. He died in 1862.
The present perfect, on the other hand, usually expresses a past event with a present connection:
3. He has gone to visit his sister.
i.e. he went recently to visit his sister, and is still there.
4. How long have you been working at the university bookshop?
i.e. he started working at the university bookshop in the past and is still working there.
5. How long did you work at the university bookshop?
i.e. he no longer works at the bookshop.
Let me know if it's still unclear!
All the best,
By emily wong in forum Ask a Teacher
Last Post: 27-Apr-2006, 22:53
By christine elizabeth in forum Ask a Teacher
Last Post: 08-Oct-2005, 04:46
By Farhaj in forum Ask a Teacher
Last Post: 28-Jul-2005, 18:49
By Dany in forum Editing & Writing Topics
Last Post: 30-Jan-2005, 17:06
By Anonymous in forum Ask a Teacher
Last Post: 13-May-2004, 02:20
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO