Forum newsfeeds |  | | Notices | You are welcome to answer questions posted in the Ask a Teacher forum as long as your suggestions, help, and advice reflect a good understanding of the English language. If you are not a teacher, you will need to state that clearly at the top of your post. Please note, all posts are moderated by our in-house language experts, so make sure your suggestions, help, and advice house the kind of information an international language teacher would offer. If not, and your posts do not contribute to the topic in a positive way, they will be subject to deletion. | 
07-Sep-2006, 23:27
| | Junior Member | | Join Date: Mar 2006 Country: England
Posts: 39
Current Location: London First Language: Polish Member Type: Student or Learner Thanks: 5
Thanked 5 Times in 4 Posts
| | Past tense in reported speech Right, that's probably trivial, but I need to know for sure :)
Which one is (more) correct? He asked me, where I live. (Because I still live there).
or He asked me, where I lived. (Because his question is referred to as the past, even though the answer hasn't changed since then).
Or both, and it's just a matter of choice/context?
Last edited by Vibovit; 07-Sep-2006 at 23:35.
| 
07-Sep-2006, 23:38
| | Senior Member | | Join Date: Mar 2006 Country: England
Posts: 671
First Language: English Thanks: 0
Thanked 4 Times in 4 Posts
| | Re: Past tense in reported speech Quote:
Originally Posted by Vibovit Right, that's probably trivial, but I need to know for sure :)
Which one is (more) correct? He asked me, where I live. (Because I still live there).
or He asked me, where I lived. (Because his question is referred to as the past, even though the answer hasn't changed since then). 
Or both? | First, there should be no comma - there is no pause in this sentence.
Second, the first clause does not need to agree in tense (or in any other way) with the second clause.
So both sentences are correct. | 
07-Sep-2006, 23:42
| | Key Member | | Join Date: Aug 2006 Country: Canada
Posts: 3,025
Current Location: Canada First Language: English Member Type: English Teacher Thanks: 4
Thanked 484 Times in 444 Posts
| | Re: Past tense in reported speech Quote:
Originally Posted by Vibovit Right, that's probably trivial, but I need to know for sure :)
Which one is (more) correct? He asked me, where I live. (Because I still live there).
or He asked me, where I lived. (Because his question is referred to as the past, even though the answer hasn't changed since then). 
Or both? | Both are fine, Vibovit. Though it's often referred to as a past, it actually has nothing to do with the past in terms of tense or time. What this means is that only the FORM is past tense, not the actual event itself.
The backshifting [so called because we move one tense shift back] that occurs for reported speech merely acts as a signal for listeners that the speech is reported/indirect speech. We can choose to report in either the same tense or we can backshift.
For speech, because the context is so rich, we don't tend to follow the normal backshifts that, say, newspapers do. Speech is more alive, more vibrant so, as you mentioned, the nowness of some reported speech can cause us to not use a backshift. | 
08-Sep-2006, 00:01
| | Senior Member | | Join Date: Mar 2006 Country: England
Posts: 671
First Language: English Thanks: 0
Thanked 4 Times in 4 Posts
| | Re: Past tense in reported speech Quote:
Originally Posted by riverkid Both are fine, Vibovit. Though it's often referred to as a past, it actually has nothing to do with the past in terms of tense or time. What this means is that only the FORM is past tense, not the actual event itself.
The backshifting [so called because we move one tense shift back] that occurs for reported speech merely acts as a signal for listeners that the speech is reported/indirect speech. We can choose to report in either the same tense or we can backshift.
For speech, because the context is so rich, we don't tend to follow the normal backshifts that, say, newspapers do. Speech is more alive, more vibrant so, as you mentioned, the nowness of some reported speech can cause us to not use a backshift. | This isn't true.
"He asked me where I live" means he is asking where I live NOW.
"He asked me where I lived" means he is asking where I lived at a particular point in the past.
The clause after 'where' has nothing to do with backshifting. | 
08-Sep-2006, 04:00
| | Key Member | | Join Date: Aug 2006 Country: Canada
Posts: 3,025
Current Location: Canada First Language: English Member Type: English Teacher Thanks: 4
Thanked 484 Times in 444 Posts
| | Re: Past tense in reported speech Quote:
Originally Posted by Coffa This isn't true.
"He asked me where I live" means he is asking where I live NOW.
"He asked me where I lived" means he is asking where I lived at a particular point in the past.
The clause after 'where' has nothing to do with backshifting. | Oh but it is true and it does, Coffa. Then again, admittedly, in the right situation, it COULD mean what you [have] stated.
A: [to C] Where do you live?
B: What did he ask you?
C: He asked me where I lived. OR He asked me where I live. | 
10-Sep-2006, 02:03
| | Junior Member | | Join Date: Mar 2006 Country: England
Posts: 39
Current Location: London First Language: Polish Member Type: Student or Learner Thanks: 5
Thanked 5 Times in 4 Posts
| | Re: Past tense in reported speech All right - thanks a lot for your explanations! | | Thread Tools | | | | Display Modes | Linear Mode |
Posting Rules
| You may post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | | All times are GMT. The time now is 14:15. |  |