You are welcome to answer questions posted in the Ask a Teacher forum as long as your suggestions, help, and advice reflect a good understanding of the English language. If you are not a teacher, you will need to state that clearly at the top of your post. Please note, all posts are moderated by our in-house language experts, so make sure your suggestions, help, and advice house the kind of information an international language teacher would offer. If not, and your posts do not contribute to the topic in a positive way, they will be subject to deletion.
Hi
I happened to use (something similar to) this sentence recently:
Our cat was caught on camera in our neighbour’s garden’s blackbird’s nest.
I would appreciate some comment on the use of the apostrophe in this instance - particularly "garden's". My understanding of it is as follows: the nest belongs to one blackbird (- or two in which case it would be blackbirds' nest). The "blackbird's nest" is found in, or belongs to, the garden - hence the apostrophe in garden's. Lastly, there is an apostrophe in neighbour's - because it is a garden belonging to one neighbour.
It sounds quite convoluted and just wondered if it could be improved?
I just wondered, how long this can extend? Like...
Our cat was caught on camera in our daughter's friend's neighbour’s garden’s blackbird’s nest.
Does anyone know of any similar grammatically correct sentences, where several consecutive words possess an apostrophe?
Thanks
David
Hi I happened to use (something similar to) this sentence recently: Our cat was caught on camera in our neighbour’s garden’s blackbird’s nest.
I would appreciate some comment on the use of the apostrophe in this instance - particularly "garden's". My understanding of it is as follows: the nest belongs to one blackbird (- or two in which case it would be blackbirds' nest). The "blackbird's nest" is found in, or belongs to, the garden - hence the apostrophe in garden's. Lastly, there is an apostrophe in neighbour's - because it is a garden belonging to one neighbour. It sounds quite convoluted and just wondered if it could be improved? I just wondered, how long this can extend? Like... Our cat was caught on camera in our daughter's friend's neighbour’s garden’s blackbird’s nest. Does anyone know of any similar grammatically correct sentences, where several consecutive words possess an apostrophe? Thanks David
I agree with Tdol. However, in the original sentence "blackbird" didn't need an apsostrophe. "Blackbird nest" functions nicely as a compound noun. That would also work in Tdol's restatement.