-
Can't...
"I can't know what you want exactly."
Using the "can't" here is wrong or doesn't make sense ?
-
Re: Can't...
Hello Volcano
It probably means "it isn't possible for me to know exactly what you mean".
Do you have more context?
MrP
-
Re: Can't...

Originally Posted by
Volcano1985
"I can't know what you want exactly."
Using the "can't" here is wrong or doesn't make sense ?
It is wrong. I don't exactly know what you want.
I can't be expected to know exactly what you want.
I can't possibly know exactly what you want.
-
Re: Can't...

Originally Posted by
MrPedantic
Hello Volcano
It probably means "it isn't possible for me to know exactly what you mean".
Do you have more context?
MrP
(Sorry, I meant:
It probably means "it isn't possible for me to know exactly what you want".
MrP)
-
Re: Can't...

Originally Posted by
Volcano1985
"I can't know what you want exactly."
Using the "can't" here is wrong or doesn't make sense ?
It doesn't make sense. Maybe it's direct translation from your native language. Maybe you want to say "I can't understand what you exactly want" and another variant without "can't": I don't know what you want exactly.
-
Re: Can't...

Originally Posted by
Harry Smith
It doesn't make sense. Maybe it's direct translation from your native language. Maybe you want to say "I can't understand what you exactly want" and another variant without "can't": I don't know what you want exactly.

Yes its my native language translation.I should use "can't" if i want to give same meaning but "don't" is suitable too.
-
-
Re: Can't...

Originally Posted by
Casiopea
Volcano, if you change the verb from
know to
understand, then, yes, your assumption is correct. Both
can't and
don't work here:
Ex: I can't understand what you want, exactly.
Ex: I don't understand what you want, exactly.
All the best.

I have to use "know" here not "understand"
-
Re: Can't...
In that case, if you have to use know, then, can't doesn't work. It doesn't make sense. Sorry.
-
Re: Can't...

Originally Posted by
Volcano1985
"I can't know what you want exactly."
Using the "can't" here is wrong or doesn't make sense ?
It makes sense. Give it a context and it makes perfect sense.
But nevertheless, it tweaks some ENL' English meters.
[looking over a table of many different food dishes]
A: Get me a plate of food.
B: I can't [possibly] know what you want.
With the addition of "possibly", it sounds better.
Normally, we don't use 'can' to discuss a one time possibility. In English, 'can' is used to discuss general possibility.
A: Where's my pen?
B: ?? Kelly can have it. ??
We use 'could/may/might' for these situations.
B: Kelly could/may/might have it.
Does this extend to the negative, <can't>? I don't think it does in as strong a fashion but anyway, the negative wouldn't be the normal first response, so out of context it sounds unnaturaL. It's a strong negation, something that is more likely to come later, as in Scenario 2.
Scenario 1:
A: Where's my pen?
B: ? Kelly can't have it. ? [reads like a prohibition, not a measure of possibility]
Scenario 2:
A: Where's my pen?
B: Kelly probably has it.
C: Kelly can't have it.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1