Forum newsfeeds 
|  | | Notices | You are welcome to answer questions posted in the Ask a Teacher forum as long as your suggestions, help, and advice reflect a good understanding of the English language. If you are not a teacher, you will need to state that clearly at the top of your post. Please note, all posts are moderated by our in-house language experts, so make sure your suggestions, help, and advice house the kind of information an international language teacher would offer. If not, and your posts do not contribute to the topic in a positive way, they will be subject to deletion. | 
17-Apr-2003, 09:10
| | Senior Member | | Join Date: Apr 2003 Country: Dalian, China
Posts: 519
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
| |  There are air and water on earth
Is this sentence right? I would have thought "There is air and water on earth" to be better, as 'air' and 'water' are uncountable.
Can anyone help?
TIA
Shane |
17-Apr-2003, 09:20
|  | Webmaster, UsingEnglish.com | | Join Date: Nov 2002 Country: England
Posts: 2,765
Current Location: London First Language: British English Thanks: 2
Thanked 46 Times in 29 Posts
| |
I agree with you Shane. It should be is. :D
__________________
Red5
Webmaster, UsingEnglish.com
Please note: I am not a teacher of English, just someone who loves the language. |
17-Apr-2003, 09:36
| | Senior Member | | Join Date: Apr 2003 Country: Dalian, China
Posts: 519
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
| |
Excellent. I can't believe that a native speaker had been paid to record this sentence for an English instruction book in China :( |
17-Apr-2003, 13:36
| | Editor, UsingEnglish.com | | Join Date: Nov 2002 Country: UK
Posts: 25,227
Current Location: Phnom Penh First Language: English Thanks: 2
Thanked 302 Times in 274 Posts
| |
Some would argure that there are two things and that the verb should be plural. In modern BE, however, the use of the plural sounds very strange. I wouldn't go so far as to say it's wrong, but I would never use the plural there. :D |
18-Apr-2003, 01:18
|  | Moderator | | Join Date: Feb 2003 Country: USA
Posts: 13,285
Current Location: North Carolina First Language: English Thanks: 73
Thanked 808 Times in 721 Posts
| | Re: There are air and water on earth
Quote: |
Originally Posted by shane Is this sentence right? I would have thought "There is air and water on earth" to be better, as 'air' and 'water' are uncountable. | Perhaps I can supply an AE perspective. IMO, it should be: "There is air and water on earth." Similiary, one might say, "There is food and drink available."
"There are air and water on earth" is not good.
8)
__________________
~R |
18-Apr-2003, 03:09
| | Senior Member | | Join Date: Apr 2003 Country: Dalian, China
Posts: 519
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
| |
Thanks a lot guys, really appreciate it.
I agree to tdol's comments: "I wouldn't go so far as to say it's wrong, but I would never use the plural there."
IMO, grammar should never be regarded as the be all and end all of a language. Sometimes even grammar is not 100% correct when used in a real life situation.
I had an argument with a Chinese English teacher yesterday about this sentence. Now, I am not criticising him in any way, but of course, not having had much experience in English language interaction in China, he was looking at this sentence from a purely grammatical perspective. When I told him that native English speakers would use 'is' and not 'are', he would not accept it. From a grammatical point of view, maybe 'are' is correct. but in general, everyday English, it's not right.
That's my view, anyway :)
Shane |
18-Apr-2003, 20:30
| | Editor, UsingEnglish.com | | Join Date: Nov 2002 Country: UK
Posts: 25,227
Current Location: Phnom Penh First Language: English Thanks: 2
Thanked 302 Times in 274 Posts
| |
A sentence like 'There are a man and a woman waiting to see you' is grammatical, but I cannot imagine many native speakers coming out with it. :( |
19-Apr-2003, 21:28
| | Moderator | | Join Date: Feb 2003 Country: USA
Posts: 13,285
Current Location: North Carolina First Language: English Thanks: 73
Thanked 808 Times in 721 Posts
| |
Quote: |
Originally Posted by tdol A sentence like 'There are a man and a woman waiting to see you' is grammatical, but I cannot imagine many native speakers coming out with it. :( | I think I might have an explanation for that. If I say "There is a man and a woman" I am linking them, making them a pair. Also, the choice of verb might have something to do with the fact that both "man" and "woman" are singular. "There are a man...." just doesn't seem natural. I think most people would naturally say "There is a man and a woman" and not think twice about it.
Finally, it could perhaps be seen as an elliptical sentence, thus: "There is a man and [there is] a woman."
What do you think?
8)
__________________
~R |
19-Apr-2003, 22:25
| | | There are earth and water.
The sentence should be considered incorrect because the author has disregarded the fact that because he used "are", he must then quantify or explain the noun. i.e. There are vast amounts of water and air on earth. Not just leave readers to their own imagination. |
20-Apr-2003, 03:05
| | Moderator | | Join Date: Feb 2003 Country: USA
Posts: 13,285
Current Location: North Carolina First Language: English Thanks: 73
Thanked 808 Times in 721 Posts
| | John D
Hey! John D, I've only seen two of your posts so far, but I have found them enjoyable and informative. Welcome to the forum!
:D
8)
Regards,
__________________
~R | | Thread Tools | | | | Display Modes |  Linear Mode | 
Posting Rules
| You may post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts
HTML code is Off | | | All times are GMT. The time now is 04:19. | |
