I feel puzzled with the following expressions. Could you tell me which are grammatically correct? which are acceptale in spoken English?
Both of you
Both you
Both of the brothers
both the brothers
both brothers
the both brothers
seems i am in a maze![]()
I agree with Bobk,but you can say for example :'Both you' is not acceptable as a free-standing noun phrase
"you both want to drive that car" (not both you)
Additionally,
These are the same. 'of' has been omitted:
Both of the brothers
Both the brothers
The difference between these is specificity.
Both the brothers <predviuosly mentioned or about to be defined>
Both brothers
The second one below is odd (). Both means two.
Both of you <'you' is plural, as in you two>
Both you and Sam
This one is not possible. A pronoun cannot be modified by a determiner, but a noun phrase can be; e.g., The both of us:
the both brothers <ungrammatical>
the brothers both <grammatical; used for emphasis>
The word both has three functions:
1.Adjective: I want both cookies.
2. Conjunction: I am both tired and lazy.
3. Pronoun: Both of us
All the best.![]()
I am out of the maze now![]()
THANK you so much for the clear and quick explanation.
You're welcome, gxiang.![]()