|
#1
| |||
| |||
| Girne Castle houses the oldest shipwreck ever ----. A) having been discovered B) being discovered C) to have been discovered D) discovered E) been discovered F) to be discovered To me, C, D, E and F are OK. Does the presence or absence of "ever" in the sentence play an important role in your choice? |
|
#2
| ||||
| ||||
| My choice: D); C) and F) are iffy. C) houses the oldest shipwreck ever to have been discovered. Note, In affirmative clauses with superlatives [e.g., 'the oldest] ever is used (especially followed by the 'to + infinitive' verb) to emphasize the uniqueness of something or someone: Neil Armstrong was the first man ever to walk on the moon. SourceChoice C) houses an infinitive but it's the kind of infinitive and how it's structured that has me wondering whether C) is awkward or not. (I'm not sure at this point. The jury is still out. More context, please.) With perfect verbs we expect the adverb ever to occur before the participle, but that's not to say the adverb can't head the infinitive phrase. It can. It's the voice, the passive voice 'have been discovered'. Is it necessary? Wouldn't D) 'discovered' suffice? As for choices D) and F), they are variants. 'to be' is optional in F) and recoverable in D). D) houses the oldest shipwreck ever discovered. F) houses the oldest shipwreck ever to be discovered. F) is iffy to me because it can express a future meaning. Which could be the reason 'to be' is omitted in D). Your choice E), shown here below, is rather awkward. 'to be' can be recoverable in D), but 'to have' cannot be recoverable here, E) ?houses the oldest shipwreck ever been discovered. =>houses the oldest shipwreck ever to have been discovered. Repair E) houses the oldest shipwreck that has ever been discovered. In short, choices C), D), and F) all house an infinitive. It's recoverable in D), which is why 'ever' works; it's overt in F) but lends itself to a future meaning, and it's overt in C) but why passive voice? All the best. |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Newbie question on relative clause | mrlocom | Ask a Teacher | 1 | 31-Jan-2007 18:19 |
| relative clause | Unregistered | Frequently Asked Questions | 2 | 09-Dec-2006 03:40 |
| non-defining relative clause | diamondrg | Ask a Teacher | 4 | 28-Jun-2006 16:14 |
| relative clause | hela | Ask a Teacher | 5 | 11-Jun-2004 00:15 |