Are they correct?

[Casiopea]

'saw' meaning noticed,

A1) I saw (that) Tyra had bags under her eyes when she wasn't wearing makeup.


'have' meaning cause to have <causative>,

A2) ?I saw Tyra have bags (drawn in) under her eyes when she wasn't wearing makeup.

Try,

I noticed (that) Tyra has bags under her eyes when she doesn't wear/isn't wearing makeup.

All the best.

[piousoul]

Thanks, Casiopea, for your clarification and kindness. I get it.

[Philly]

1. I wouldn't risk saying ...
2. I wouldn't like to say...
3. I am unwilling to say...

I am unwilling to say that. The word 'would' can be interpreted as "unless you or someone else points out something I may have overlooked."

[BobK]

It's a mixture of 1 and 2, with a dash of 3! What none of them (1,2 or 3) has is the suggestion that saying whatever would be a little more than the speaker meant; to say that would be going too far.

b

[Casiopea]

Loads of wiggle room there.

[piousoul]

Loads of wiggle room there.

Wow, Casiopea, you wows me again with this wiggle room.

My wild shot in the dark: hesitation.

[Casiopea]

wiggle room. The American Heritage&#174; Dictionary of the English Language: Fourth Edition. 2000.

[piousoul]

wiggle room. The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language: Fourth Edition. 2000.

Thanks, Casiopea, for the link. I got it.