-
demand, suggest, propose...
Could you please tell me which of the varieties (below) of the sentence "I demand that he should come." are corect?
I demand (that) he should come.
I demand (that) he comes.
I demand (that) he come.
I demand (that) he apologised.
-
Re: demand, suggest, propose...

Originally Posted by
Lenka
Could you please tell me which of the varieties (below) of the sentence "I demand that he should come." are corect?
I demand (that) he should come.
I demand (that) he comes.
I demand (that) he come.
I demand (that) he apologised.
The first three are fine; the fourth one fails to agree in tense. It would either be "I demand that he apologise" (present tense) or "I demanded that he apologised" (past tense).
-
Re: demand, suggest, propose...
In my experience, if this is from a text or is in a test, usually it is a discussion of the subjunctive and only the third sentence would be considered correct. I think I recall, though, that "should" is acceptable in BE...?
What do you think Anglika?
-
Re: demand, suggest, propose...
-
Re: demand, suggest, propose...
Hi,
1) I demand (that) he should come.
2) I demand (that) he comes.
3) I demand (that) he come.
Which sounds the most natural to you?
-
Re: demand, suggest, propose...
Could you please tell me which of the varieties (below) of the sentence "I demand that he should come." are corect?
I demand (that) he should come.
I demand (that) he comes.
I demand (that) he come.
I demand (that) he apologised.
Anglika,this looks to be a subjunctive;a special kind of subjuntive with present tense which has no --s in the third person singular verbs.
Demand,suggest,insist,recommend,propose...
We insist that he resign.
I propose that she be appointed.
I demand that he come.-Is the only correct option.
Regards,
1948.
Last edited by rj1948; 13-Jun-2008 at 15:37.
-

Originally Posted by
Lenka
Could you please tell me which of the varieties (below) of the sentence "I demand that he should come." are corect?
I demand (that) he should come.
I demand (that) he comes.
I demand (that) he come.
I demand (that) he apologised.
Anglika wrote:
The first three are fine; the fourth one fails to agree in tense. It would either be "I demand that he apologise" (present tense) or "I demanded that he apologised" (past tense).
I agree with Anglika on the first three.
I'm a bit puzzled over the fourth
"I demanded that he apologised" (past tense).
What's the purpose of the 'ed' on apologise?
?? I asked that he apologised. ??
I asked that he apologise.
??I demanded that he went to the meeting.??
I demanded that he go to the meeting.
My guess is that Lenka put in "apologised" as a potential "subjunctive" form. Correct me if I'm wrong, please, Lenka.
Last edited by riverkid; 14-Jun-2008 at 02:11.
-
Re: demand, suggest, propose...

Originally Posted by
Lenka
Could you please tell me which of the varieties (below) of the sentence "I demand that he should come." are correct?
I demand (that) he should come.
I demand (that) he comes.
I demand (that) he come.
I demand (that) he apologised.
Say:
I demand that he come.
-
Re: demand, suggest, propose...

Originally Posted by
riverkid
The first three are fine; the fourth one fails to agree in tense. It would either be "I demand that he apologise" (present tense) or "I demanded that he apologised" (past tense).
I agree with Anglika on the first three.
I'm a bit puzzled over the fourth
"I demanded that he apologised" (past tense).
What's the purpose of the 'ed' on apologise?
?? I asked that he apologised. ??
I asked that he apologise.
??I demanded that he went to the meeting.??
I demanded that he go to the meeting.
My guess is that Lenka put in "apologised" as a potential "subjunctive" form. Correct me if I'm wrong, please, Lenka.
The idea is that I demanded and he apologised.
-
Re: demand, suggest, propose...
"I demanded that he apologised" (past tense).

Originally Posted by
Clark
The idea is that I demanded and he apologised.
I can't, at this moment, see any way that the sentence above, in red, could be glossed/understood in the manner you've suggested, Clark. Now that doesn't absolutely exclude the possibility you've suggested.
Perhaps Anglika can suggest a context where it might work.
Similar Threads
-
By Luciferd in forum General Language Discussions
Replies: 16
Last Post: 05-Jun-2010, 12:43
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1