Quote:
|
Originally Posted by wendy Quote: |
Originally Posted by I I was on your Web site, and you have some pictures and videos of you guys partying like ******* animals
Can I replace it with " your guys partying"? | Quote: |
Originally Posted by Tdol You can't replace it with 'your' unless they belong to the person in some way. | Quote: |
Originally Posted by MikeNewYork This is one of those situations in which the possessive + gerund form doesn't work very well. |
but Quote: |
Originally Posted by teacher from other board ==> Well, yes, and no. Yes, if you want it to mean, 'just your friends partying', and no, if you want it to mean, 'you and the guys partying'. |
I'm still confused. Can I replace it with " your guys partying"? |
'you guys' means, you
people (i.e. 'you' is plural). If we omit the word 'guys', like this,
1. pictures of
you partying
the resulting meaning is singular 'you', like this,
2. pictures of you, John, partying.
The pictures are of one person only: John.
The word 'guys' is important because it tells us 'you' is plural, and not singular.
Next, if we change 'you' to 'your', like this,
3. pictures of
your guys partying
the resulting meaning is the 'guys' belong to you. That is, your friends, they alone, were in the pictures; you weren't in the pictures.
If we change 'your' back to 'you', like this,
4. pictures of
you guys partying
'partying' functions as a modifier. It describes what 'you guys' were doing in the pictures.
Consider the structure of the phrase:
5. pictures of you guys partying
Structure: pictures (that were taken) of people (doing something)
Participles generally answer the question "Doing what?", whereas gerunds answer the question "What?"
EX: Partying is fun.
Question: What is fun?
Answer: Partying. (
Gerund)
EX: A partying animal
Question: An animal
doing what?
Answer: Partying. (
Participle)
EX: Pictures of you guys (Doing what?)
partying. (
Participle)
:D