|
#11
| ||||
| ||||
| Quote:
A person whose job (that it) is to repair pipes is a plumber. |
|
#12
| ||||
| ||||
| This is rather a complicated question for me. Principal clause A plumber is a person --> what person? attributive defining clause whose job --> ??? object clause? that it is to repair pipes. Nothing is clear, sorry. I can not ask questions from main clauses to the subordinate ones. Therefore I can not see any sense, I have to confess. Maybe I am caught in an endless loop with this plumber. Could you find another example of such elipsis and reveal it to me please? Or explain from another point of view. Michael |
|
#13
| ||||
| ||||
| OK. No worries. First, let's take a look at how our example sentence was formed. Two clauses become one: 1. A plumber is a person. 2. Her job is to repair the pipes. Conjunction A plumber is a person and her job is to repair the pipes. Here the phrase her job functions as the subject of the verb (is), but when we relativize it (give it an adjectival function), its position in the structure changes and with it its syntactic function. That is, whose job doesn't function as a subject but as a head, which is why expletive-it is inserted here: Relative A plumber is a person whose job it is to repair the pipes. Does that help? |
|
#14
| ||||
| ||||
| Quote:
A person whose job it is to repair the pipes is called a plumber. |
|
#15
| |||
| |||
| Hi Bob and Casiopea Can I use whichever when I refer to people? If I take into consideration your reply to the post [ and I am sure you are right], than the answer to my question is affirmative. However, I am confused. I have not had the slightest idea that whichever can be used when talking about people. I have always thought that whoever is the pronoun used for people. Would you be so kind and help with this problem? That`s a huge lack from my part, or, how should I say it better? Thank you very much. Last edited by Teia; 25-Aug-2007 at 20:23. |
|
#16
| ||||
| ||||
| subject verb A plumber is a person, /and her job is to repair the pipes/. A plumber is a person /whose job is to repair the pipes/. A plumber is a person, /and her job it is to repair the pipes/. Or should I place / between job and it? How many subordinate clauses here? Don't you try to say that there are two? I still can not catch the idea, and you will be tired of this question soon. But! Is a plumber is usually a woman in your country? That is pretty funny Ok, let's stop joking. We have two subjects, the first is a notional word "job" and the the second one is a substitute for "job". I have never heard about "head" as a part of a sentence. If you will send me some link to read, I will be grateful. I can understand that it is very often used as a formal subject in impersonal statements. It is raining. But I think it is not our case. Why should I put a formal subject here if I have a real one (job)? Michael |
|
#17
| ||||
| ||||
| Can I use whichever when I refer to people? Which is used for asking for a specific choice from a limited number of possibilities (both persons and things). You can not ask "who of you", but you have to say "which of you". Michael |
|
#18
| |||
| |||
| Quote:
Thank you. My question referred to the usage of whichever vs. whoever, not to who or which, although who of you is used, as well: Who of you know any one with special powers? - Yahoo! Answers India ps. I`m not sure if this usage is Standard English, though. |
|
#19
| ||||
| ||||
| The rules for use of compound pronouns (formed with some-, any-, no- and others) are the same. Michael |
|
#20
| |||
| |||
| Quote:
Read the Summary in the link below, please: "...The most common distribution of the forms is therefore as follows (though variations may be heard)...." English relative clauses - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Which might be one of those variations the author is speaking about. |
![]() |
| Bookmarks |
| Tags |
| relative pronouns |
| Thread Tools | |
| Display Modes | |
| |
Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| whichever | curious | Ask a Teacher | 3 | 02-Apr-2006 21:30 |
| Whichever occurs later | Hanka | Ask a Teacher | 3 | 27-Sep-2005 12:45 |
| whichever and whoever | jiang | Ask a Teacher | 4 | 20-Feb-2005 01:36 |