-
after "help"
Could you tell me if this sentence below is grammatically correct?
"The Canadian police officers are sent there to help police the American football maches."
For me, after "help..." sounds a bit unnatural.
I think "help + object (people) + preposition ..." or
"help + verb..." sounds natural.
And why "the" isn't put in front of "police"?
-
Re: after "help"

Originally Posted by
ivygreen
Could you tell me if this sentence below is grammatically correct?
"The Canadian police officers are sent there to help police the American football maches."
For me, after "help..." sounds a bit unnatural.
I think "help + object (people) + preposition ..." or
"help + verb..." sounds natural.
And why "the" isn't put in front of "police"?
The sentence is correct. Police is used here not as a noun but as a verb.
The Canadian police officers are sent there to help maintain the security of the American football maches by carrying out a patrol.
police - vb. = 1.maintain the security of by carrying out a patrol
police - Definitions from Dictionary.com
Help can be followed by a verb too:
Vitamin E may help protect you.
help + verb + noun vs help + noun + verb
Last edited by Teia; 09-Oct-2007 at 19:51.
-
Re: after "help"
Dear Teia,
Thank you very much for your detail and kind explanation.
I can understand totally. Thank you so much.
-
Re: after "help"
However, using "police" as a noun in the beginning of the sentence and "police" as a verb later in the sentence strikes me as not very good style. I would have chosen a different verb.
[not a teacher]
-
Re: after "help"

Originally Posted by
Barb_D
However, using "police" as a noun in the beginning of the sentence and "police" as a verb later in the sentence strikes me as not very good style. I would have chosen a different verb.
[not a teacher]
I agree with you Barb. I would have chosen a different verb too.
-
Re: after "help"

Originally Posted by
ivygreen
Dear Teia,
Thank you very much for your detail and kind explanation.
I can understand totally. Thank you so much.
You are most welcome! If I were to choose, I would use a different verb instead of police, as Barb has already said.
-
Re: after "help"
Thank you very much, again. I see. I understand it.
Similar Threads
-
By alan in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 4
Last Post: 18-Jul-2004, 23:59
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1