keep a secret

[bread]

She kept it a secret.
She kept it as a secret.
Which one is correct?

thanks!

[bread]

She kept it a secret.
She kept it as a secret.
Which one is correct?

thanks!

[Francois]

'She kept it secret' is better IMO.

FRC

[Francois]

'She kept it secret' is better IMO.

FRC

[Tombraiders]

Both of these are good to use.
keep it secret = keep it a secret

But in my opinion, these two usages may have subtle difference in meaning.

keep it a secret - I won't tell anybody

keep it as a secret - I won't tell anybody nor I want anybody else to find out the truth.

[Tombraiders]

Both of these are good to use.
keep it secret = keep it a secret

But in my opinion, these two usages may have subtle difference in meaning.

keep it a secret - I won't tell anybody

keep it as a secret - I won't tell anybody nor I want anybody else to find out the truth.

[rocos]

I think that they are all right.

[gonghai]

She kept it a secret.
She kept it as a secret.
Which one is correct?

thanks!

in my opinion i think they are both correct

the first one i think it means the secret between u and me
and the second one is the secret put safely away and never mentioning it ever again

[gonghai]

She kept it a secret.
She kept it as a secret.
Which one is correct?

thanks!

in my opinion i think they are both correct

the first one i think it means the secret between u and me
and the second one is the secret put safely away and never mentioning it ever again