2Likes -
1 Post By banderas -
1 Post By stuartnz
-
satisfying vs. satisfactory
I can't see much difference between the adjectives satisfying and satisfactory. 
With which of the two words would you complete the following sentence?
Sales are up 20% from last year, which is very _______ .
-
Re: satisfying vs. satisfactory

Originally Posted by
Lenka
I can't see much difference between the adjectives
satisfying and
satisfactory.

With which of the two words would you complete the following sentence?
Sales are up 20% from last year, which is very _______ .
satisfactory = meeting minimum requirements
satisfying = giving pleasure
Which one do you choose ?
Last edited by banderas; 27-Mar-2008 at 15:20.
Reason: typo
-
Re: satisfying vs. satisfactory

Originally Posted by
Lenka
I can't see much difference between the adjectives
satisfying and
satisfactory.

With which of the two words would you complete the following sentence?
Sales are up 20% from last year, which is very _______ . what I meant to say is for some people satisfactory grade might be satisfying, for others it might be quite unsatisfying.
Last edited by banderas; 27-Mar-2008 at 15:26.
Reason: typo
-
Re: satisfying vs. satisfactory
Oh, I see. Thank you, I think I can understand the difference now.
I just have some other questions dealing with satisfaction:
What is the difference between "dissatisfied" and "unsatisfied"?
And what about "dissatisfactory" and "unsatisfactory", "dissatisfying" and "unsatisfying"?
Are there any differences at all?
-
-
Re: satisfying vs. satisfactory
Banderas, thank you very much. 
I just have a few questions to this topic:

Originally Posted by
banderas
I am always unsatisfied with my English as there is always something to improve= my English is good as for non-native speaker but I want more then good, I am dissatisfied.
I am dissatisfied with my level of Italian, as I have no time to learn and I do not know any simple words at all.
I don't understand why you said that you are dissatisfied (with your English) - I highlighted in red. Why did you not say "I am unsatisfied"?
Here's the other question of mine: If one is not satisfied, is he or she unsatisfied or dissatisfied? If someone is dissatisfied, does it mean he or she is not satisfied?
-
Re: satisfying vs. satisfactory

Originally Posted by
Lenka
Banderas, thank you very much.
I just have a few questions to this topic:
I don't understand why you said that you are dissatisfied (with your English) - I highlighted in red. Why did you not say "I am unsatisfied"?
I meant unsatisfied, sorry, a typo
Here's the other question of mine:
If one is not satisfied, is he or she unsatisfied or dissatisfied? If someone is dissatisfied, does it mean he or she is not satisfied? now you are asking abou being not satsified, for me not satsified = unsatsified whereas dissatisfied is much more then not satisfied.
By the way I susspect that the thing with "not satisfied" is like with "impatient", "unhelpful" etc. one says not "helpful", " not patient" and so on, if you know what I mean.
-
Re: satisfying vs. satisfactory

Originally Posted by
banderas
now you are asking abou being not satsified, for me not satsified = unsatsified whereas dissatisfied is much more then not satisfied.
I'm not a teacher, but I agree entirely. Unsatisfied is a passive absence of satisfaction - "I ate my dinner, but it left me unsatisfied, I need something more."
Dissatisfied is an active condition. It's not the mere absence of satisfaction, it's the presence of the opposite. "This meal was awful, cold and badly cooked. I am VERY dissatisfied".
-
Re: satisfying vs. satisfactory

Originally Posted by
stuartnz
I'm not a teacher, but I agree entirely. Unsatisfied is a passive absence of satisfaction - "I ate my dinner, but it left me unsatisfied, I need something more."
Dissatisfied is an active condition. It's not the mere absence of satisfaction, it's the presence of the opposite. "This meal was awful, cold and badly cooked. I am VERY dissatisfied".
It is so good to know that you sometimes agree with me though
.
I have posted a new thread "it is you who", Stuart, your opinion is important to me. There is also a thread posted by someone called "Usage of I" where I asked native speakers something , If you are free, could you take a look, please?
Lenka, are you satisfied with our explanations?
-
Re: satisfying vs. satisfactory
Yes, I am satisfied now :). Thank you both.
Similar Threads
-
By chiharu in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 3
Last Post: 15-Dec-2005, 13:37
-
By jiang in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 3
Last Post: 10-Dec-2004, 13:57
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1