adverb of place

[navi tasan]

)To which of the cases a, b, or c do the sentences 1, 2 and 3 correspond:

1-I called him at the office.
2-I called him, at the office.
3-At the office, I called him.

a-I am at the office and am giving the phone call FROM the office.
b-He is at the office and I am calling him from elsewhere.
c-Both of the above are possible.

B)Consider also:

4-Where did you call him?
Does this one correspond to a, b, or c?

(I know that I have asked a question very much like part A before. I just want to check something. These adverbials are a big thing with me.)

[RonBee]

I would only use one of the sample sentences, thus: "I called him at the office." The meaning of that one is indicated by: "He is at the office and I am calling him from elsewhere."

If I wanted to indicate where the caller was I would say something like: "I called him from the office."

8)

[ESL-lover]

I would only use one of the sample sentences, thus: "I called him at the office." The meaning of that one is indicated by: "He is at the office and I am calling him from elsewhere."

[Tdol]

)To which of the cases a, b, or c do the sentences 1, 2 and 3 correspond:

1-I called him at the office. c, but b is more likely as a meaning
2-I called him, at the office. no need for comma
3-At the office, I called him. a, but rather unusual

a-I am at the office and am giving the phone call FROM the office.
b-He is at the office and I am calling him from elsewhere.
c-Both of the above are possible.

B)Consider also:

4-Where did you call him?
Does this one correspond to a, b, or c?
c

(I know that I have asked a question very much like part A before. I just want to check something. These adverbials are a big thing with me.)

[RonBee]

Um, TDOL, that one is a little confusing as it looks like the entire thing is a quote. It's hard to tell what belongs to navi tasan and what belongs to you. :?

8)

[Tdol]

I like to make things challenging. <point taken>

[RonBee]

I like to make things challenging. <point taken>

LOL, nothing succeeds like success. :wink:

8)

[Tdol]

I'm one of the few people that can use challenging as a near synonym of lazy.