A preposition followed by another one
In the name of the Merciful Allah,
Hi, is it possible in English to follow a preposition by another one directly without a conjunction?
Re: A preposition followed by another one
In principle, yes, e.g.
From inside the house he heard a terrible scream.
although note that this applies only to certain preposition combinations (most notably 'from' + a simple locative preposition such as 'inside, above, below,...').
Re: A preposition followed by another one
Re: A preposition followed by another one
... and after many phrasal verbs it's hard not to - example: I'm fed up with this.
b
Re: A preposition followed by another one
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BobK
... and after many phrasal verbs it's hard not to - example: I'm fed up with this.
b
As much as I fear a repeated accusation of hair-splitting, I must take issue with your answer: 'up' in the expression that you cite is an adverbial particle, not a preposition!
Re: A preposition followed by another one
Quote:
Originally Posted by
philo2009
As much as I fear a repeated accusation of hair-splitting, I must take issue with your answer: 'up' in the expression that you cite is an adverbial particle, not a preposition!
Fear not! ;-)
from where? from (inside the house) -- the object of the prep is a prepositional phrase
Agreed, 'up' is an adverb in 'fed up with'.
Re: A preposition followed by another one
Quote:
Originally Posted by
svartnik
Fear not! ;-)
from where? from (inside the house) -- the object of the prep is a prepositional phrase
The object of a preposition is not a prepositional phrase, it's called the complement of the preposition, which can be realized by a noun (phrase) or a pronoun, or in the phrase in question by an adverbial.
The whole phrase from inside the house is a prepositional phrase.
Re: A preposition followed by another one
But the adverbial is a prepositional phrase consisting of the noun phrase following the preposition inside, is that correct?
With 'house' being the headword whichever way you care to look at it?
Re: A preposition followed by another one
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pedroski
But the adverbial is a prepositional phrase consisting of the noun phrase following the preposition inside, is that correct? :up:
With 'house' being the headword whichever way you care to look at it?
Like I wrote earlier, the whole phrase is a prepositional phrase.
But if you want to break the phrase into the parts of speech, then you get:
two prepositions
one determiner
one noun
At clause level, you get:
an adverbial within a prepositional phrase.
Re: A preposition followed by another one
Quote:
Originally Posted by
svartnik
Fear not! ;-)
from where? from (inside the house) -- the object of the prep is a prepositional phrase
Indeed it is: the embedded prepositional phrase functions nominally as object/complement of the first preposition. I have nowhere stated otherwise.
Your disagreement with me appears to rest on a misreading of the original question, which was simply whether a preposition can be directly followed by another, to which the answer is patently 'yes'!!