1Likes -
1 Post By gabber
-
doing or undergoing something
Hello,
I would like to know whether my assumption about the following
is right or not:
If I say "Kenneth had his best friend killed" it means that Kenneth
asked someone to kill his best friend for him.
But if I say "Kenneth had his best friend kill for him" it means that Kenneth
asked his best friend to go and kill someone else.
So in general, in a sentence like "A had B killed/fired/thrashed..." (when
I use a past simple for the verbs kill/fire/thrash...) it means that B undergoes something that A set in motion.
And in a sentence like "A had B kill/fire/thrash C" (when I use a present tense for the verbs kill/fire/thrash...) it means B does something to C because he was told to do so by A.
Can anyone verify this for me, please?
-
Re: doing or undergoing something
Filip,
You understand, and express, the meanings quite correctly. Just one minor quibble: the verb forms "killed," "fired," "thrashed" are not past tense verbs - they're passive participles. And your "kill," "fire," and "thrash" are not simple present tense verbs - they're what grammarians call "bare" infinitives.
You write English very well. You'd get an A in my class.
-
Re: doing or undergoing something
Hooray, an A! That means a lot to me, coming from a true English speaking teacher. Thanks very much for confirming my theory and teaching me the correct grammatical terms that came with it.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1