2Likes -
Gerund vs Infinitive
I have two questions about following two sentences
(A) The doorman held the door for her passing through.
(B) The doorman held the door for her to pass through.
Q1. If both sentences are grammatically correct?
Q2. If they are, what is the difference in the meaning?
Thank you.
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
yun
I have two questions about following two sentences
(A) The doorman held the door for her passing through.
(B) The doorman held the door for her to pass through.
Q1. If both sentences are grammatically correct?
Q2. If they are, what is the difference in the meaning?
Thank you.
(A) is incorrect.
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
yun
I have two questions about following two sentences
(A) The doorman held the door for her passing through.

(B) The doorman held the door for her to pass through.
Q1. If both sentences are grammatically correct?
Q2. If they are, what is the difference in the meaning?
Thank you.
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
bhaisahab
(A) is incorrect.
Thank you for your prompt reply.
Would you explain the reason?
In fact, I can't see any grammatical problem.
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
yun
Thank you for your prompt reply.
Would you explain the reason?
In fact, I can't see any grammatical problem.
A is correct.
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
svartnik
A is correct.
The question is whether you would say like that, svartnik.
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
svartnik
A is correct.
Are you a native speaker?
I am sorry but I need a serious answer with a grammatical explanation.
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
yun
Are you a native speaker?
I am sorry but I need a serious answer with a grammatical explanation.
(A) The doorman held the door for her passing through.
What part of speech, in your opinion, is 'passing' in this sentence?
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
yun
I have two questions about following two sentences
(A) The doorman held the door for her passing through.
(B) The doorman held the door for her to pass through.
Thank you.
I don't like either of them. They both seem to indicate that the lady is going to pass through the door that the doorman is holding, rather than through the doorway. Is she in spirit?
The doorman held the door while she walked through.
I know this could also be read wrongly, but there's something about the original expression that invites the above interpretation.
Bhai, the 'passing' in 'passing through' is a gerund.
The police cleared the road for the Queen's passing by.
-
Re: Gerund vs Infinitive

Originally Posted by
Raymott
I don't like either of them. They both seem to indicate that the lady is going to pass through the door that the doorman is holding, rather than through the doorway. Is she in spirit?
The doorman held the door while she walked through.
I know this could also be read wrongly, but there's something about the original expression that invites the above interpretation.
Bhai, the 'passing' in 'passing through' is a gerund.
The police cleared the road for the Queen's passing by.
Would you say: The police cleared the road for the Queen's passing by.
or: The police cleared the road for the Queen's entourage to pass by.
Similar Threads
-
By Dinhtuong in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 3
Last Post: 20-Jun-2009, 14:35
-
By kledor in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 01-Apr-2009, 02:56
-
By daisy1352 in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 3
Last Post: 30-Nov-2008, 14:48
-
By blue_jay975 in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 10
Last Post: 21-Apr-2008, 10:27
-
By demir in forum Ask a Teacher
Replies: 1
Last Post: 07-Nov-2007, 18:30
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules

Search Engine Optimization by
vBSEO 3.6.1