Teaching vs Training Vs Facilitation

[anupumh]

Hi,

How and in what ways are these different from each other??

Teacher
Trainer
Instructor
Facilitator
Coach
Mentor

Thanks

[Abstract Idea]

Originally Posted by anupumh

Hi,

How and in what ways are these different from each other??

Teacher
Trainer
Instructor
Facilitator
Coach
Mentor

Thanks

I think you should add
Professor
Guru
to your list.

Regarding guru, you may read: http://www.usingenglish.com/forum/as...e-teacher.html
And regarding language training you may read http://www.usingenglish.com/forum/ge...-training.html

[Tdol]

There's a jargon element here and some happen to be in vogue at a particular time. Before I left the UK, we were being encouraged to refer to students as customers. I agree with what Raymott says about some rigid methods being training in the link above.

A mentor gives guidance/advice, especially to the inexperienced. Sports have coaches but the term is being used for teaching- I think it's supposed to sound positive and encouraging. Facilitator changes the roles and doesn't have the same power relationship that teacher/student has- it casts them as (near-) equals in the learning process instead of the transmission of knowledge from the learned to the unlearned, though the term never really took off in my experience- a few people used it but it never caught on in the UK.

[Tdol]

There's a jargon element here and some happen to be in vogue at a particular time. Before I left the UK, we were being encouraged to refer to students as customers. I agree with what Raymott says about some rigid methods being training in the link above.

A mentor gives guidance/advice, especially to the inexperienced. Sports have coaches but the term is being used for teaching- I think it's supposed to sound positive and encouraging. Facilitator changes the roles and doesn't have the same power relationship that teacher/student has- it casts them as (near-) equals in the learning process instead of the transmission of knowledge from the learned to the unlearned, though the term never really took off in my experience- a few people used it but it never caught on in the UK.

[anupumh]

Originally Posted by Tdol

There's a jargon element here and some happen to be in vogue at a particular time. Before I left the UK, we were being encouraged to refer to students as customers. I agree with what Raymott says about some rigid methods being training in the link above.

A mentor gives guidance/advice, especially to the inexperienced. Sports have coaches but the term is being used for teaching- I think it's supposed to sound positive and encouraging. Facilitator changes the roles and doesn't have the same power relationship that teacher/student has- it casts them as (near-) equals in the learning process instead of the transmission of knowledge from the learned to the unlearned, though the term never really took off in my experience- a few people used it but it never caught on in the UK.

How would you explain the difference between a Trainer and a Teacher..??

[Abstract Idea]

If I may please, I would like to change the original question a little bit. Or rather ask another question to teachers and academics at UsingEnglish about this subject:

If a student called you by any of the names above, namely
Teacher
Trainer
Instructor
Facilitator
Coach
Mentor
Professor
Guru
Master
Doctor
would you feel offended or upset? I am also talking about college level professors - maybe a professor could be offended to be called as a teacher?

[Tdol]

Originally Posted by ymnisky

[/B]would you feel offended or upset? I am also talking about college level professors - maybe a professor could be offended to be called as a teacher?

Some might, but generally we use names not positions; I'd rather they used my name than called me 'teacher', but some students find that hard to do because that would be rude in their culture.

[Raymott]

Originally Posted by ymnisky

If I may please, I would like to change the original question a little bit. Or rather ask another question to teachers and academics at UsingEnglish about this subject:

If a student called you by any of the names above, namely
Teacher
Trainer
Instructor
Facilitator
Coach
Mentor
Professor
Guru
Master
Doctor
would you feel offended or upset? I am also talking about college level professors - maybe a professor could be offended to be called as a teacher?

You can't really compare them because they can mean different things in different settings.
In fact we don't have "college level professors" in Australia. If you're a professor, you work at a university. A university professor can be all those things, but in most cases, they'd rather be researching. Teaching is often an unpleasant chore for which they often have little natural talent. This applies to many academics (PhDs etc.).
I believe this also applies to Britain.

[Abstract Idea]

Originally Posted by Raymott

You can't really compare them because they can mean different things in different settings.
In fact we don't have "college level professors" in Australia. If you're a professor, you work at a university. A university professor can be all those things, but in most cases, they'd rather be researching. Teaching is often an unpleasant chore for which they often have little natural talent. This applies to many academics (PhDs etc.).
I believe this also applies to Britain.

OK Raymott. That is exactly what I think when I use the term "professor".
I know often teaching is an unpleasant chore, specially to freshman or sophomore students. One of the things I asked was whether such professor could feel upset for being inadvertently called teacher by a first-year student.

When I said "college level" I was using the AmE terminology (that is university), you have already told me the difference: http://www.usingenglish.com/forum/as...niversity.html
I am sorry about the misunderstanding.

[Raymott]

Originally Posted by ymnisky

OK Raymott. That is exactly what I think when I use the term "professor".
I know often teaching is an unpleasant chore, specially to freshman or sophomore students. One of the things I asked was whether such professor could feel upset for being inadvertently called teacher by a first-year student.

When I said "college level" I was using the AmE terminology (that is university), you have already told me the difference: http://www.usingenglish.com/forum/as...niversity.html
I am sorry about the misunderstanding.

The reality is that no-one would call their professor "teacher" in any English-speaking country I know of.
Consider Professor John Smith PhD.
They would call him Professor Smith, Dr. Smith, Professor, Doctor, or John.
This is usually sorted out in the first class, where he will say something like "You may call me Professor Smith, or Doctor Smith or John - as long as you do it politely - but not Mr. Smith. I worked a long time for that doctorate! <laughter>".
So, no he generally wouldn't be offended. He'd be vaguely amused and puzzled, depending on his personality, because he may never have heard it before.
However, if you called him "teacher" in a way that was obviously sarcastic - implying that he wasn't much of a teacher at all, then yes, he would quite rightly be offended. I've never seen this happen.

PS: In fact, no one at all is called "teacher" that I can think of.
A school teacher is either 'Sir', 'Miss", Mr Smith, Miss Smith, Mrs Smith. Perhaps in some progressive schools these days, it might be John or Mary.
(Again, this BrE, AusE usage, which tends to be similar as far as education systems go).