[General] participle or gerund?

Status
Not open for further replies.

number4940

New member
Joined
Apr 28, 2010
Member Type
Other
(I'm not a teacher.)

A friend posted a sentence that goes like this:

"She is puzzling."

and meant by that, that she was doing a puzzle. (It was meant to be a pun.) She said that she meant "puzzling" in the sense of a gerund, which she said so that it would not come across as that she meant that she was confusing.

I thought that it could not be a gerund.

I figured that puzzling in that case would be a participle. Usually I wouldn't debate over something like this, but she teaches English.

Can anyone confirm one way or the other what part of speech "puzzling" represents here?
 

yuriya

Member
Joined
Apr 23, 2010
Member Type
Student or Learner
Native Language
Korean
Home Country
South Korea
Current Location
South Korea
(I'm not a teacher.)

A friend posted a sentence that goes like this:

"She is puzzling."

and meant by that, that she was doing a puzzle. (It was meant to be a pun.) She said that she meant "puzzling" in the sense of a gerund, which she said so that it would not come across as that she meant that she was confusing.

I thought that it could not be a gerund.

I figured that puzzling in that case would be a participle. Usually I wouldn't debate over something like this, but she teaches English.

Can anyone confirm one way or the other what part of speech "puzzling" represents here?

You are right on the track. "Puzzling" is a participle in either sense in the pun above. However, I'd prefer to call it an adjective rather than a participle when it is used in the normal sense (confusing, that is).
Anyway, FYI, from a non-native speaker's point of view this kind of problems are pretty much straight forward, and I wonder why native speakers have trouble identifying them.
 
Last edited:

Barb_D

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Member Type
Other
Native Language
American English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
While I knit, I am knitting.
While I write, I am writing.
While I do a puzzle, I am doing a puzzle, not "puzzling."

It is a pun but it's harder for native speakers to follow because we would not refer to that activity as "puzzling."
 

number4940

New member
Joined
Apr 28, 2010
Member Type
Other
You are right on the track. "Puzzling" is a participle in either sense in the pun above. However, I'd prefer to call it an adjective rather than a participle when it is used in the normal sense (confusing, that is).
Anyway, FYI, from a non-native speaker's point of view this kind of problems are pretty much straight forward, and I wonder why native speakers have trouble identifying them.

Thanks. I would have simply considered it an adjective as well if it were to mean "confusing."

As far as it being straight forward, it is, but I trusted that someone who says she is a teacher would not have made such a mistake. I even suggested to her that I thought it was a participle, and she still said it was a gerund. Imagine if she's grading tests and making mistakes like this.

Thanks.
 

tedtmc

Key Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2006
Member Type
Interested in Language
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
Malaysia
Current Location
Malaysia
"She is puzzling."

It is an adjective, definitely not a gerund.

She is used to puzzling(gerund) us.

not a teacher
 

Raymott

VIP Member
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Member Type
Academic
Native Language
English
Home Country
Australia
Current Location
Australia
Thanks. I would have simply considered it an adjective as well if it were to mean "confusing."

As far as it being straight forward, it is, but I trusted that someone who says she is a teacher would not have made such a mistake. I even suggested to her that I thought it was a participle, and she still said it was a gerund. Imagine if she's grading tests and making mistakes like this.

Thanks.
Some teachers/grammarians/academics call all of these "-ing" words gerunds, whether they are nouns or participles. This is possibly what she learnt at school.
You should ask her whether she considers "puzzling" to be a noun. In majority opinion about the definition of "gerund", if it's not a noun, it's not a gerund.
She likes puzzling. That is a gerund/noun.

Note Wikipedia:
"In linguistics, gerund (abbreviated ger) is a term used to refer to various non-finite verb forms in various languages:"

As applied to
English, it refers to the usage of a verb (in its -ing form) as a noun (for example, the verb "learning" in the sentence "Learning is an easy process for some"). This is also the term's use as applied to Latin; see Latin conjugation.
So, the use of "gerund" is not consistent across languages. Of course, that's no excuse to get it wrong in English, but maybe she learnt her grammar when learning French. Grammar has not been a priority for English teachers in the last few decades; and that is why ESL learners probably understand some English grammar better than some English teachers. Sad but true.
 
Last edited:

albertino

Senior Member
Joined
May 27, 2007
Member Type
Other
Native Language
Chinese
Home Country
Hong Kong
Current Location
Hong Kong
(I'm not a teacher.)

A friend posted a sentence that goes like this:

"She is puzzling."

and meant by that, that she was doing a puzzle. (It was meant to be a pun.) She said that she meant "puzzling" in the sense of a gerund, which she said so that it would not come across as that she meant that she was confusing.

I thought that it could not be a gerund.

I figured that puzzling in that case would be a participle. Usually I wouldn't debate over something like this, but she teaches English.

Can anyone confirm one way or the other what part of speech "puzzling" represents here?
(not a teacher)
In that sense, it is a present participle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top