I wonder "who she is" or "who is she"

Status
Not open for further replies.

seagirl

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2004
Member Type
Student or Learner
Hi all. I have a problem with using "wh-verb-subject " or "wh-subject-verb" in the following contents:

i wonder who is she.
i wonder who she is.

i wonder who is reading this.
i wonder who reads this.

I wonder what did she see.
I wonder what she sees.

can anyone tell me which ones are correct?
 

Tdol

No Longer With Us (RIP)
Staff member
Joined
Nov 13, 2002
Native Language
British English
Home Country
UK
Current Location
Japan
In every case, the second is right. These are indirect questions, so shouldn't have question word order. ;-)
 

Dixybig273

New member
Joined
Jul 25, 2005
Hi there,

In this situation, i wouldn't consider "I wonder 'who she is' or who is she'" as a question. It is not even a rethorical question. It is more like a speculation... If such is the case, I wonder "who she is" is the right answer.

Dixy
 

Casiopea

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Member Type
Other
MehmetBaskan said:
We can not say "I wonder who is she?" ;-)
Nice addition, Mehmet, and it's correct, but . . . could you tell us why? :-D :up:
 

seagirl

Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2004
Member Type
Student or Learner
Hi all. I'm very happy to see your replies:) I have another question concerning the same issue here.

" Do you know how thunderstorm is formed? "
"Can you tell me who that girl is? "

Are they the correct way of asking questions?
 

Casiopea

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Member Type
Other
You're welcome. :-D

Try,

Do you know how thunderstorms are formed? :up:
Do you know how a thunderstorm is formed? :up:
Can you tell me who that girl is? :up:

To form an object (e.g., that girl is) take the statement and move who to the front, like this,

Statement: That girl is who?
Object: . . . who that girl is?
Example: Can you tell me who that girl is?

That girl is the subject, is is the verb and who is the object, or in this case, since is is a form of the verb BE, who functions as a predicate nominal, technically speaking.

Other examples,

She is who?
I wonder who she is.

The next example does not require WH-movement. 'Who' is the subject,

John is reading this.
Who is reading this?
I wonder who is reading this? (grammatical) :up:

The example below requires WH-movement because what functions as an object in that sentence. When the WH-word functions as a subject movement isn't required:

She saw what?
I wonder what she saw?
I wonder what she did see? (did is added for emphasis)


She sees what?
I wonder what she sees?
I wonder what she does see? (does is added for emphasis)

Thunderstorms are made how?
Can you tell me how thunderstorms are made?

Hope that helps out some. :up:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top