- For Teachers
the Haiti-ans need to come to America.
Some people are all,What about
the strain on our resources?
Like, when I had this garden party
for my father's birthday, right?
I said RSVP because
it was a sit-down dinner.
But people came that,
like, did not RSVP,
what "come that" mean?
...that did not respond to my RSVP request?
...that habitually failed to respond to RSVPs?
...that did not send RSVPs?
...that did not understand the concept of RSVP?
or something else?
RSVP is used a verb frequently here, simply meaning "to respond to an invitation."
Did you RSVP to Peter's wedding? = Did you send back the reply card?
They didn't RSVP = They did not let me know that they were coming (or let me know that they were not coming -- they just didn't let me know at all because they didn't respond at all).
I'm not a teacher, but I write for a living. Please don't ask me about 2nd conditionals, but I'm a safe bet for what reads well in (American) English.
"came that" still doesn't make any sense to me.
what you have wrote it is just wrong, wouldn't it be "But people WHO CAME, did not RSVP." not "But people came who did not RSVP".?
It's not wrong, it's just a little unusual.
Some children came who had not been invited.
Several birds appeared who had not been there earlier.
Many people cook who have never had a cookery lesson.
I think I have an idea where the confusion comes from. Usually the word "who" comes right after the noun in such structures, as in your sentence:
1) People who came did not RSVP.
"People" is a noun in this sentence and "who" comes right after it. This is the usual way. This is also the case in the following sentence (which we haven't yet discussed).
2) People who did not RSVP came.
It is also a correct sentence. As in the previous sentence, "who" comes right after the noun "people".
But sometimes, we use the construction you've encountered.
3) But people came who did not RSVP.
You may not believe me, but as you can see, native speakers who posted in this thread did not oppose this construction.
PS: Emsr2d2 was quicker than me.
Last edited by birdeen's call; 21-Sep-2011 at 01:56.