cypriot77
New member
- Joined
- Mar 15, 2013
- Member Type
- English Teacher
- Native Language
- Polish
- Home Country
- Poland
- Current Location
- Poland
Dear colleagues,
I have come across a problem in an exercise I can't explain to my students. While completing a gapped exercise on modal verbs, we found the following sentence (the whole text is about 16th century explorers): "On a ship only some 35 metres long, it can't have been easy for the 80 or so crew to live comfortably. Exploration was part of war and rivalry with other nations, so these voyages MIGHT INVOLVE attacks on other ships and towns."
Now, since the modal verb refers to a past activity, everyone thought that MIGHT HAVE INVOLVED would be a better option here. I have browsed through a number of grammar books and couldn't find any explanation for this. Might + present infinitive is only used to express present or future possibility.
The only explanation I might (sic!) have, is that MIGHT INVOLVE refers to some general/regular possible acitivity in the past, while MIGHT HAVE INVOLVED would refer to individual situations.
I would be grateful for any logical explanation to the problem.
I have come across a problem in an exercise I can't explain to my students. While completing a gapped exercise on modal verbs, we found the following sentence (the whole text is about 16th century explorers): "On a ship only some 35 metres long, it can't have been easy for the 80 or so crew to live comfortably. Exploration was part of war and rivalry with other nations, so these voyages MIGHT INVOLVE attacks on other ships and towns."
Now, since the modal verb refers to a past activity, everyone thought that MIGHT HAVE INVOLVED would be a better option here. I have browsed through a number of grammar books and couldn't find any explanation for this. Might + present infinitive is only used to express present or future possibility.
The only explanation I might (sic!) have, is that MIGHT INVOLVE refers to some general/regular possible acitivity in the past, while MIGHT HAVE INVOLVED would refer to individual situations.
I would be grateful for any logical explanation to the problem.