# Thread: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

1. ## Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

Hello,
Unit 20 contains "going to (do)" lessons.

1st lesson:
'I think the baby's hungry.' 'Yes, I know. ________________ her.'

a) I'm going to feed b) I'm feeding c) I was going to feed

I thought only a) is correct. But only a) and c) is the correct answer.

How can that be?

2. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

Originally Posted by bolshi
Hello,
Unit 20 contains "going to (do)" lessons.

1st lesson:
'I think the baby's hungry.' 'Yes, I know. ________________ her.'

a) I'm going to feed b) I'm feeding c) I was going to feed

I thought only a) is correct. But only a) and c) is the correct answer.

How can that be?
a) and c) are both possible.

3. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

I know that. Because the program said the only correct answer is a) and c).

I'd like to know why c) works as well.

4. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

c = I was about to feed her (when you spoke).

5. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

Originally Posted by bolshi
Hello,
Unit 20 contains "going to (do)" lessons.

1st lesson:
'I think the baby's hungry.' 'Yes, I know. ________________ her.'

a) I'm going to feed b) I'm feeding c) I was going to feed

I thought only a) is correct. But only a) and c) is the correct answer.

How can that be?
I agree with a and c. I could even make a case for b.

6. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

For native speaker it seems to be consequential. Sorry, I'm a German :)

There are several different examples within the lesson I'll ask later. For me the 'going to' rule based on a logic rule concerning future.

But does exist a rule where I derive 'c' from too?

@5jj What does 'when you spoke' mean?

7. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

c) suggests that the speaker already had the plan/intention before the person said that the baby was hungry.

8. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

Great! Now I know how it works ;)

Thanks a lot!

9. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

The problem with exercises of this sort is that the writer often has a specific point of grammar in mind, ignoring the fact that, in real life, all sorts of things might be going through the minds of the speakers. As Mike suggested, (b) culd be natural in real life - though I don't recommend that you choose it in this type of exercise.

10. ## Re: Problems with Exercise from English Grammer in Use

Originally Posted by bolshi
I know that. Because the program said the only correct answer is a) and c).
This doesn't make sense. If there's an only correct answer, it's either a) or c).
Do you mean that the program gave both a) and c) as correct answers?
Your original might make sense with 'answers are'.

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•