Kind / Kinds

Status
Not open for further replies.

Casiopea

VIP Member
Joined
Sep 21, 2003
Member Type
Other
jack said:
kind of _______ (Singular Noun)
kinds of ______ (Plural Noun)

How come it doesn't work here?
1. What kind of friends do you have?
2. What kinds of friend do you have? (This doesn't make sense with that rule?)

Should they work?
 
P

padmaratna

Guest
jack said:
I have spent quite some time on these but I can't figure out what exactly do they mean.

Are these correct? If not, why? What do they mean?

1. What kinds of chocolate do you have?
2. What kind of chocolates do you have?
3. What kinds of chocolates do you have?

2
 

jack

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2004
padmaratna said:
So that is another exception? I don't get it, why?
Why not?
1. What kinds of chocolate do you know?

Instead of:
2. 1. What kind of chocolates do you know?
 

Steven D

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2004
Member Type
English Teacher
Using Kind Of andSort Of





The expressions kind of or sort of to mean "rather," "partially," or "somewhat" are nonstandard.
____________________________________________________________

It's more accurate and realistic to say that theyare not typical of formal writing. Other than that, they're used all the time. ____________________________________________________________







Both expressions literally mean "type of" or "variety of."
Incorrect: The child felt kind of lonely. - :arrow: This is actually correct. There's nothing wrong with saying that.




Correct: The child felt somewhat (or rather) lonely. - :arrow: This is also correct.

Correct: The kestrel is a kind of falcon.
(A type or variety of falcon)

http://englishplus.com/grammar/00000231.htm

There's nothing nonstandard about using "kind of" and "sort of" in in this way. One may not find them in formal writing, but that's obvious. I find it somewhat displeasing to always have to justify language that we commonly use by saying "but it wouldn't appear in formal writing". There is nothing wrong with using "kind of" and "sort of". There is nothing "nonstandard" about saying "It's kind of cloudy now." or "It's kind of cold in here." This is standard in everyday spoken English. The whole world of ESL/EFL students/learners are not using EAP (English for Academic Purposes), and neither am I.

Despite what this site says about "kind of" and "sort of", we can say "kind of " and "sort of". It is not incorrect language. If you want something that sounds more "serious", then use "somewhat" or "rather". I use those as well, but I still say "kind of".






 

Steven D

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2004
Member Type
English Teacher
jack said:
I have spent quite some time on these but I can't figure out what exactly do they mean.

Are these correct? If not, why? What do they mean?

1. What kinds of chocolate do you have?
2. What kind of chocolates do you have?
3. What kinds of chocolates do you have?

All three are correct. I think it's more usual to use "kind of". I would say, "What kind of chocolate do you have?"

This could mean more than one kind of chocolate just as "kinds of chocolate" could mean more than one kind of chocolate.

I think one would say either "chocolates" or "chocolate" in this case. It would depend on the expectations of the speaker. Would the speaker be expecting a variety of chocolates?
 
V

vladz

Guest
I never thought that "kind/kinds of" are that difficult to analyze.
 

Steven D

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2004
Member Type
English Teacher
vladz said:
I never thought that "kind/kinds of" are that difficult to analyze.

They're not difficult to analyze. I think "kind of" is more likely to be used than "kinds of".

What kind of chocoate do you have?
 

jack

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2004
Thanks.

What do these mean?
1. What kind of friends do you have?
2. What kinds of friend do you have?
 

Steven D

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2004
Member Type
English Teacher
jack said:
Thanks.

What do these mean?
1. What kind of friends do you have?
2. What kinds of friends do you have?
They mean the same thing to me. If someone uses "kinds", then the emphasis is on more than one type of friend. However, using "kind" could still be taken to mean more than one type of friend.


In the second sentence, "friend" should be plural.
 
Last edited:

jack

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2004
Do these mean the same thing?

1. What kinds of car do you have?
2. What kinds of cars do you have?
 

Steven D

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2004
Member Type
English Teacher
jack said:
Do these mean the same thing?

1. What kinds of car do you have?
2. What kinds of cars do you have?
Only use number 2.

It's not logical for "kinds" to be plural and "car" to be singular. The noun "car" is countable.

What kinds of fruit do you have? What kind of fruit do you have?

What kinds of fish do you have? What kind of fish do you have?

I believe I would use "kind" most of the time in my speaking.

If there is some sort of rule that calls using "kind" and not "kinds" informal, I'm not aware of it.

What kind of food do you like? food - not countable

What kind of vegetables do you like? - vegetables - countable - Use the plural form.
 
Last edited:

Steven D

Senior Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2004
Member Type
English Teacher
X Mode said:
They mean the same thing to me. If someone uses "kinds", then the emphasis is on more than one type of friend. However, using "kind" could still be taken to mean more than one type of friend.

I overlooked "kinds".

What kind of friends do you have?

or, "What kinds of friends do you have?"

but not, "What kinds of friend do you have?
 

jack

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2004
In the second sentence, "friend" should be plural.
1. What kinds of friend do you have? (I don't get it. So is this wrong? Why does it have to be plural?)

Are these correct? What do these mean?
2. What kind of presents do you have? (Asking about the same types of presents?)
5. What kind of present do you have? (Asking about one present?)

What do these mean? I can't figure out the difference in meaning between them.
3. What kinds of presents do you have?
4. What kinds of present do you have? (If this is correct, why isn't #1 correct?)

5. What kinds of car do you have?
6. What kindsof cars do you have?

7. These kinds of film are popular.
8. These kinds of films are popular.
 
Last edited:
A

AintFoolin

Guest
1 is incorrect, in needs to be 'friends'. You can't have more than one kind of friend if you only have one friend

2 & 5 are correct afaik, but 5 is pretty odd
2 assumes all the presents are of the same type
5 is asking about just one present

4 is incorrect for the same reason 1, if you're going to use kinds, you have to use presents. One present cannot be of two or more kinds.

5b is incorrect for the same reason as 1 and 4
 

jack

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2004
2 & 5 are correct afaik, but 5 is pretty odd
5. What kinds of car do you have?
1. What kinds of car do you have? (So this means you have differents kinds of car parts? What does this sentence mean?)

Are these correct? If not, why? What do they mean?
2. This means you have differents kinds of car parts of car. (I don't have a determiner between 'of' and 'car', does that mean 'car' is uncountable here? 'Car' as in not a whole car? What does this sentence mean?)
3. This means you have differents kinds of car parts of a car. (Car parts from one car?)
4. This means you have differents kinds of car parts of cars? (Car parts from many cars?)
 
Last edited:

RonBee

Moderator
Joined
Feb 9, 2003
Member Type
Other
Native Language
American English
Home Country
United States
Current Location
United States
You can't say, "What kinds of car do you have?" Instead, you have to say, "What kinds of cars do you have?"


:)
 
A

AintFoolin

Guest
jack said:
1. What kinds of car do you have? (So this means you have differents kinds of car parts? What does this sentence mean?)

your numbering is screwed up, you listed two sentences as '5'

if you notice, i said:
> 5b is incorrect for the same reason as 1 and 4

when i said 5 was ok, i was referring to this sentence of yours:
> 5. What kind of present do you have?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top