Can you start a sentence with "and"? |
|
|
| Votes: 4544 |
Comments: 73 |
Added: August 2003 |
Comments:
| Willbut - 19th September 2003 22:18
|
| You can start a sentece, a paragraph or even a text with 'and', IMO.
|
| |
| Stunz - 25th September 2003 01:39
|
| Of course you can. Find any writer acknowledged to be a great who doesn't.
|
| |
| Italianbro - 15th November 2003 00:58
|
| And yet, there are many people, who say that a sentence should not start with "and"; though I disagre with them, I wouldn't abuse it as a starter.
|
| |
| Dave - 15th November 2003 14:36
|
| No you cant start with and. And you should know this! :D
|
| |
| willbut - 25th November 2003 23:57
|
| The Nenerable Bede, the first great English author, starts his book with 'and', and he was writing in Latin.
|
| |
| willbut - 25th November 2003 23:58
|
| Sorry, the Venerable Bede.
|
| |
| lkjhfdsa - 27th November 2003 04:51
|
| You are all obviously Americans.
|
| |
| ad - 29th November 2003 01:47
|
| You can, but you shouldn't.
|
| |
| willbut - 28th December 2003 00:27
|
| I'm British. :-)
|
| |
| fin - 3rd February 2004 15:06
|
| Of course you *can* start a sentence with "and," but that's artistic license, not grammatical correctness. No journalist will write a hard news article containing a sentence that starts with "and." It's grammatically wrong.
|
| |
| chasegehrig - 23rd February 2004 02:23
|
| I guess those guys who wrote the Bible weren't hard jornalists then...
|
| |
| chasegehrig - 23rd February 2004 02:24
|
oops "journalists"
See Genesis 1:25
|
| |
| WileECoyoteSG - 27th February 2004 20:23
|
Every grammatical source I have checked including some authors and English professors state that it IS grammatically correct to start a sentence with "AND." It can be overused; however, it is not incorrect to use it.
Have you ever seen "Finding Forrester"?
|
| |
| ntianu - 14th March 2004 06:05
|
| It is absolutely wrong to start a sentence with and. And only serves as a conjunction b/w 2 phrases, sentences, or words.
|
| |
| naz - 24th November 2005 23:09
|
| i dont think so god people r gettin crazy starting a sentence with and
|
| |
| pual - 2nd December 2005 02:00
|
| it is perfectly acceptable to start this sentence with But even tough it is a part of FANBOYS -for, and, nor, but, or, yet, so- I can start a sentence with it because of the usage to coordinate two independent clauses (groups of words that can stand alone as sentences). Here are two examples, with the independent clauses in brackets: [We started to go home], but [we had run out of gas]. Most likely, many people believe they should not start a sentence with a coordinating conjunction because their grammar teachers in grade school discouraged them from doing so. Yet such a rule is completely unjustifiable. When grammar teachers teach youngsters the essentials of sentence structure, they most likely explain that coordinating conjunctions are used to hold together elements within a sentence. Therefore, they may discourage students from starting sentences with coordinating conjunctions because they are trying not only to explain conjunctions but also to help their students learn to avoid sentence fragments like this one: She was a nice girl. And smart, too. In this example, using "and" after the period is wrong because the second "sentence" is not really a sentence at all: it has neither a subject nor a verb. Thus, youngsters carry forward into adulthood the notion that a sentence should never begin with a coordinating conjunction, especially not with "and" or "but." In fact, however, professional writers have started sentences with coordinating conjunctions throughout history
|
| |
| theophrastus - 16th January 2006 02:57
|
| You wouldn't be against someone starting a sentence with "Additionally..." or "In addition..." - meaning, "Here's another point that complements the last." So why can't "And" be used the same way, even in a scholarly essay?
|
| |
| E.Cornelius - 18th August 2006 16:23
|
| I guess im old school,I was taught not to begin a sentence with and.
|
| |
| rufaidah - 29th August 2006 07:59
|
| no cause it dose not make any sence and if you want to make sure go back to school and ask!!!
|
| |
| Robert - 29th August 2006 21:42
|
| And they said it couldn't be done.
|
| |
| jeanette - 11th October 2006 05:08
|
| No, you can't, however the english language would be much easier on all of us if we could.
|
| |
| Aquesha Stith - 2nd November 2006 17:34
|
| I believe you can't because and is a conjucntion and it should be in a sentence not at the begining.
|
| |
| john b - 14th December 2006 08:00
|
| As far as I can see there is no rule anywhere that says you can't start a sentence with a conjunction. In fact, it can add a great deal of emphasis to the written word. And that's a fact!
|
| |
| D - 1st February 2007 14:17
|
| It depends, according to the Plain English rules you can if it makes the sentence clearly and it can be a way of cutting down long unwieldy sentences. It is best to avoid it if you can though!
|
| |
| Keijo Sandvik - 2nd February 2007 11:56
|
"And it came to pass after seven days, that the waters of the flood were upon the earth." Hmmm. It looks like this grammatical "misconception" has been around for quite some time.
Naughty King James!
|
| |
| Terry - 2nd February 2007 12:52
|
| It's not grammatically correct, it's often used in advertising text where space is at a premium. And it makes a sentence stand out when it is!
|
| |
| Aristocrat - 3rd February 2007 20:52
|
| Your old grammar school teacher probably taught you not to start a sentence with a conjunction. This is a good rule for children learning English, and a good practice in many applications, however it is not an absolute rule of any sort. Many accomplished authors recognize the value in bending such "rules" to manipulate the language.
|
| |
| elske - 22nd February 2007 16:53
|
| Not in legal documents.
|
| |
| steve - 9th April 2007 05:26
|
| you cannot start a sentence with "and". and is a coordinating conjunction.Coordinating conjunctions, also called coordinators, are conjunctions that join two items of equal syntactic importance. As an example, the traditional view holds that the English coordinating conjunctions are for, and, nor, but, or, yet, and so (which form the mnemonic FANBOYS). Note that there are good reasons to argue that only and, but, and or are prototypical coordinators, while nor is very close. So and yet share more properties with conjunctive adverbs (e.g., however), and "for...lack(s) most of the properties distinguishing prototypical coordinators from prepositions with clausal complements" [1]. Furthermore, there are other ways to coordinate independent clauses in English.
|
| |
| Ladycoreopsis - 13th April 2007 07:55
|
| I find it amusing that many of the people posting comments stating, "No, you can't start a sentence with and," have some of the worst grammar errors and typos in this poll.
|
| |
| Mhairi - 19th April 2007 15:53
|
| My opinion is that you cannot start a sentence with "and", however, English is a living language which incorporates neologisms all the time. Are there any actual English teachers who can help with this debate? Opinions seem to be so divided!
|
| |
| BabyJai - 2nd May 2007 10:27
|
It actually depends in which instance you're starting "and" off with.
In a formal or even a general essay, it should not be used; however, in literature, it is allowed.
Those who do not believe, that even in literature, "and" could be used to start off a sentence has been concealed from good literature for much too long. >_>;;
|
| |
| jeff - 7th May 2007 23:51
|
| Of course you can, it just depends on the context, especially on sentence structure. You can easily start a sentence with and, so long that it is a simple sentence inversion technique where "and" is heading a dependent clause, though it usually shouldn't, except in select cases. As a simple sentence, though, it is grammatically incorrect.
|
| |
| Hamish - 18th May 2007 15:12
|
It is not really a question open to opinion; it is perfectly valid to start a sentence with 'and'. As Paul says in his post of 2nd December, it has been embedded in the masses by teachers.
Imagine a specific example; you are writing a letter explaining your impoverished position and asking for money. You have a few paragraphs explaining the situation and then it would be fine to say: "And so I turn to you for support....."
Obviously it must be used correctly, all words can be used incorrectly, so can 'and'.
Re: ntianu's post of 14th March.
He/she says "It is absolutely wrong to start a sentence with and. And only serves as a conjunction b/w 2 phrases, sentences, or words."
We are mature enough to not mock you for using the word to start a sentence as it is used as a noun describing the word. However, you say it can be used to join sentences. If you do not start a sentence with the word, how do you manage this?
|
| |
| nairubi - 28th June 2007 20:51
|
| no you cant start a and.
|
| |
| LLC - 29th June 2007 00:57
|
| The person should have written... The word "and" only serves as a conjunction between two phrases, sentences, or words.
|
| |
| Ross - 2nd August 2007 14:50
|
| I see no problem with starting a sentence with 'and' if you are writing informally. I doubt you will see sentences beginning with 'and' in formal writing. Many well-respected authors start their sentences this way and I think it is a matter of style and purpose rather than a hard and fast rule of grammar.
|
| |
| Mike - 7th August 2007 22:09
|
| The word "And" joins two phrases. If there is nothing before "And" then the word is incorrect.
|
| |
| Tony - 7th September 2007 00:36
|
you can start a sentence using anything you want. in other words, yes it is certainly possible.
ex.
And that's why the Tigers lost the baseball game.
but is it grammatically correct?
yes.
"they are just words, they don't control us."
-Dane Cook
|
| |
| ashley - 15th September 2007 06:05
|
| Is Hemingway famous?
|
| |
| daeste - 4th October 2007 10:01
|
| Of course you can start a sentence with the word and, however whether this is gramatically correct is a different matter.
|
| |
| Paul - 4th October 2007 16:49
|
| Yes you can. I am a college English professor in Colorado, and the rules have changed over the years. Using a conjunction (and, but…) to start a sentence is a stylistic choice to typically indicate a pause. And you should experiment more often!
|
| |
| Amanda - 10th October 2007 02:24
|
| I believe you can use a and at the begining of a sentence. P.S. To the British- The American english is a bit different than yours.
|
| |
| Amanda - 10th October 2007 02:39
|
| Excuse me. I meant to say "an" and.
|
| |
| Stew - 16th October 2007 21:22
|
| And I think you can. Because I said so. Ain't that da truth. Grammar don't matter!
|
| |
| EMY - 19th October 2007 00:59
|
YES, you can begin a sentence with "and" as long as you use it properly.
"And" is an interesting word.
The question was "Can you start a sentence with "and"? Not many but you can!
|
| |
| MiMi - 28th October 2007 18:53
|
| Yes you can. Sometimed you don't have other choice =) !
|
| |
| Judy Taylor - 1st November 2007 03:13
|
| When writing in a conversational tone it is appropriate. It is not appropriate in more formal communications.
|
| |
| Jonathan Richards - 12th November 2007 10:18
|
| Shakespeare, Milton, Heller, Cervantes.... All have used "And" at the beginning of a sentence. Oh, and the Oxford Dictionary of English Usage says it's okay. And the bible too.
|
| |
| Rob - 29th November 2007 19:51
|
| it is done in the NYTimes everyday.
|
| |
| jolo - 9th December 2007 18:46
|
The word "and" is not only a conjunction." And" can be used to capture a meaning or concept other than its common use in traditional thought. Our schooling should not limit our use of words. It is not just about "artistic license" .
"And then there was the word, and the word became ....."
|
| |
| H - 10th February 2008 05:07
|
| Of course you can start a sentence with the word and. You can also start it with the word but. I have asked quite a few people I know what they thought about this. Most who have taken any type of writing class in addition to required courses such as business writing or writing ettiquette agree that you most certainly are able to do this. Folks I asked who have taken only required courses or no course at all seem to go with the thought this is not acceptable...
|
| |
| PinkFox - 10th February 2008 22:44
|
| Of course you can start off a sentence with "and"! Although this would not be good to write in a grade school paper.
|
| |
| Connor - 11th February 2008 02:42
|
| NO YOU CAN NOT
|
| |
| Jay - 26th February 2008 01:04
|
"And," "but" and "or" are conjunctions - they join sections of sentences into one complete thought. You *can* begin a sentence with a conjunction, but you must take care to make sure that your sentence is a complete thought. For example - "But if you take a wrong turn, you will end up in Timbucktu" is a complete sentence but "And pro golfers are not athletes is a fragment.
That's the reason teachers told us so often, "don't start sentences with prepositions," people were too careless...
|
| |
| melissa - 18th April 2008 01:37
|
| no you can't! it is not proper! :P
|
| |
| Faiz khan,English lecture - 19th April 2008 04:02
|
| Because that is not a completely professional or a casual way to start an initial sentence.however, we can adjoin a sentanec and use it in between the two sentences.
|
| |
| John - 19th April 2008 04:31
|
And," "but" and "or" are conjunctions - they join sections of sentences into one complete thought. You *can* begin a sentence with a conjunction, but you must take care to make sure that your sentence is a complete thought. For example - "But if you take a wrong turn, you will end up in Timbucktu" is a complete sentence but "And pro golfers are not athletes is a fragment.
That's the reason teachers told us so often, "don't start sentences with prepositions," people were too careless...
melissa - 18th April 2008 01:37
no you can't! it is not proper! :P
Faiz khan,English lecture - 19th April 2008 04:02
Because that is not a completely professional or a casual way to start an initial sentence.however, we can adjoin.
|
| |
| Aarvee - 6th May 2008 17:35
|
| Sometimes. For example. And that was the end of that.
|
| |
| Asad - 10th May 2008 16:31
|
| one can star a sentence with "and : and there is no harm in it.
|
| |
| Jvmac - 30th May 2008 04:25
|
Writers use it for emphasis or effect.
A good writer will use it to good effect, it is also a easy way out if you are too dumb to construct a proper sentence. It should not be taught to students learning English!
|
| |
| Victor - 12th June 2008 09:10
|
| According to an Australian Government publication 'Choosing Your Mark" by Dr George Stern " conjunctions ... dont't - join only clauses: they can also link sntences or paragraphs to each other,"
|
| |
| Joe - 8th August 2008 22:38
|
| I'm thick so I don't know
|
| |
| cat - 9th August 2008 15:06
|
| im pretty sure u cant but i wish u cud cos i need 2 in this history essay!
|
| |
| dance - 18th August 2008 23:38
|
| No you cant! didnt your teatcers ever teach ya that????????
|
| |
| Charles Whittlesey - 19th August 2008 17:38
|
Not only can you start a sentence with "and," but even if the rules specified you couldn't, the best writers understand that most rules of English can be bent or even broken on a case-by-case basis if they're handled judisciously. The goal is good writing, not the meticulous and slavish adherence to a set of standards. That's for bureaucrats and listmakers, not people who want to communicate efficiently.
I agree with Emerson: "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds."
|
| |
| Microsoft Word - 22nd August 2008 11:40
|
I agree entirely with Charles Whittlesey (19th August 2008 17:38).
Most people here who answer no have incorrect grammar. That tells me something.
|
| |
| banana - 27th August 2008 03:23
|
you CAN start a sentence with and, cause in every book i've read in my life there has been at least one sentence that starts with and in it. in school i was taught no to do that on papers and essays. but for some sentences it is necessary. so therefore you CAN start a sentence with the word "and"
and if anybody disagrees, heres another reason : because i said so and im cool.
thank you have a nice day.
|
| |
| Master - 27th September 2008 15:32
|
| IT IS perfectly acceptable to start a sentence with AND and BECAUSE and BUT--simple-minded English teachers tell you not to and they wanted to help you guards against writing sentence fragments. But they were wrong not to tell you the truth (probably because they didn't know the truth!) Look it up in Fowlers and the Oxford Guide to Writing! And, yes, I saw Finding Forester and during the scene where he explains that you CAN start a sentence with AND and BECAUSE, I nearly jumped up and cheered!!!!
|
| |
| Lance Crossley - 5th October 2008 05:39
|
| KJV of old testament starts many a verses with And - and is perhaps the reason the education system frowns upon it.
|
| |
| greggles - 5th October 2008 16:07
|
| no you can't, some say u can write "And in conclusion, ...." but you should say "So in conclusion ..." this is just like all the other examples, IF YOU CANT WRITE IT IN SCHOOL, YOU CANT WRITE IT IN COLLEGE SO YOU SHOULDNT WRITE IT AT ALL. thanks
|
| |
| BeckyP - 9th October 2008 16:40
|
| hate u everyone who said YES¬!!!
|
| |
| Craig - 10th October 2008 17:16
|
| Of course you can. Read the bible and read some more books. You will see that many professional journalists and authors begin sentences with "And."
|
| |
You must vote before you can post a comment.
Browse our language polls:
|
 |
| Poll Statistics |
Polls: 776
Votes: 204,207
Comments: 2,073 |
|
