keannu
VIP Member
- Joined
- Dec 27, 2010
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Korean
- Home Country
- South Korea
- Current Location
- South Korea
Is this "should have withheld" a mistake or an exceptional usage of "should+have+p.p" meaning past obligation?
Considering the context, it seems to have to be "had to withheld" as it already happened and doesn't mean any regret.
ex)The death of Martha of Graham of April 1, 1991 finally premitted Agnes de Mille to publish her biography of the dancer, after nearly twenty-five years of work and four years of waiting. It is a measure of de Mille's respect for Graham that she should have withheld until after the subject's death what is by any standard an affectionate and appreciative account of her life and art, rather than risk offending Graham's own sense of herself in the slightest degree...
Considering the context, it seems to have to be "had to withheld" as it already happened and doesn't mean any regret.
ex)The death of Martha of Graham of April 1, 1991 finally premitted Agnes de Mille to publish her biography of the dancer, after nearly twenty-five years of work and four years of waiting. It is a measure of de Mille's respect for Graham that she should have withheld until after the subject's death what is by any standard an affectionate and appreciative account of her life and art, rather than risk offending Graham's own sense of herself in the slightest degree...