Which is the correct sentence?

Which is the correct sentence:

1. Did you have your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?
2. Did you had your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?
3. Have you had your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?

Or is there any other alternative asking this question?

Thanks in advance.

Regards,
SF

soulfly said:

Which is the correct sentence:

1. Did you have your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?:tick:
2. Did you had your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?:cross:
3. Have you had your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?:tick:

Or is there any other alternative asking this question?

Thanks in advance.

Regards,
SF

Click to expand...

#3 is the normal question if you are asking whether someone has finished a meal; #1 is used if you are unsure whether or not that person managed to get a meal.

I can't at the moment think of other ways to ask this ;-)

soulfly said:

W
[*]Have you had your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?

Click to expand...

If we remove 'your' the question could also be asked if the time for the meal wasn't over yet.
e.g. It's 11:00. Have you had breakfast?

Thank you Anglika and Clark for you help.

Regards,
SF

soulfly said:

Which is the correct sentence:

1. Did you have your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?:tick:
2. Did you had your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?:cross:
3. Have you had your breakfast/ lunch/ dinner?:tick:

Or is there any other alternative asking this question?

Thanks in advance.

Regards,
SF

Click to expand...

The clarification give by anglica is suffice. However I think in the third one use of a time expession in the past will add to the meaning.