Ju1ian
Junior Member
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2009
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Javanese
- Home Country
- Japan
- Current Location
- Japan
Now that I have your attention,
Q1. "We will ship the product within 2 weeks of the receipt of the payment."
Can you say "2 weeks from" instead of "2 weeks of"? A quick Googling shows many (but fewer) people use 'from' but please confirm whether this is strictly correct. I feel 'within' and 'from' are kind of redundant and shouldn't be used together.
Q2. "The size of the material was measured by using a special device."
Can you just say "...was measured using a special device", that is, without "by"? Again, the omission of the 'by' is quite commonly seen, but I feel this 'by' is indeed necessary. Here is my reasoning.
"John was killed by using a knife." --->Means the murderer used a knife to kill John.
"John was killed using a knife." --->Means John was using a knife when he was murdered.
Q3. "Simultaneously to the merger of the company, John was appointed the chief of the marketing division."
"Simultaneous to the merger of the company, John was appointed the chief of the marketing division.
Which sentene is grammatically correct? Both? I feel the first one may be grammatically sounder, but the second one actually sounds as natural for some reason. Plus, I have sometimes seen/heard people use adjectives like adverbs to begin a sentence. The most notable example is "Most important, this decision will affect...", which has been bothering me, actually. Shouldn't this be 'Most importantly,"?
Another (unconvincing) theory of mine is, the second sentence is grammatically incorrect, but the following sentence is correct; "Simultaneous to the merger of the company, John's appointment to the chief of the marketing division became official." The reasoning here is, 'merger' and 'appointment' are both nouns and they can be both modified by the adverb "simultaneous".
Q1. "We will ship the product within 2 weeks of the receipt of the payment."
Can you say "2 weeks from" instead of "2 weeks of"? A quick Googling shows many (but fewer) people use 'from' but please confirm whether this is strictly correct. I feel 'within' and 'from' are kind of redundant and shouldn't be used together.
Q2. "The size of the material was measured by using a special device."
Can you just say "...was measured using a special device", that is, without "by"? Again, the omission of the 'by' is quite commonly seen, but I feel this 'by' is indeed necessary. Here is my reasoning.
"John was killed by using a knife." --->Means the murderer used a knife to kill John.
"John was killed using a knife." --->Means John was using a knife when he was murdered.
Q3. "Simultaneously to the merger of the company, John was appointed the chief of the marketing division."
"Simultaneous to the merger of the company, John was appointed the chief of the marketing division.
Which sentene is grammatically correct? Both? I feel the first one may be grammatically sounder, but the second one actually sounds as natural for some reason. Plus, I have sometimes seen/heard people use adjectives like adverbs to begin a sentence. The most notable example is "Most important, this decision will affect...", which has been bothering me, actually. Shouldn't this be 'Most importantly,"?
Another (unconvincing) theory of mine is, the second sentence is grammatically incorrect, but the following sentence is correct; "Simultaneous to the merger of the company, John's appointment to the chief of the marketing division became official." The reasoning here is, 'merger' and 'appointment' are both nouns and they can be both modified by the adverb "simultaneous".