# Thread: Which one is the equivalent?

1. Member
Join Date
Oct 2009
Posts
128

## Which one is the equivalent?

Hi, my dear teachers, I am desperate for your help again.
1. Line AB is four times as long as Line CD.
2. Line AB is four times longer than Line CD.
3. Line AB is three times longer than Line CD.
I am confused about these sentences. Some teachers tell me sentence 2 is the equivalent to sentecnce 1, while others tell me sentence 3 is equivalent to sentence 1. Those who think sentence 3 is the equivalent say the second sentence means "Line AB is five times as long as Line CD".
Which one is the equivalent to sentence 1? You please give a detailed answer. A world of thanks to you!

2. Member
Join Date
Mar 2010
Posts
120

## Re: Which one is the equivalent?

(1) and (3) are equivalent.

In (1), AB is expressed in terms of CD, that is: AB = 4CD.

* * * * <----AB
*______<----CD

Consider (3): AB is longer than CD. By how much is it longer than CD?

*|* * *| <---- AB
*_______<---- CD
_<----->_
___3CD___

So, AB is 3CD longer than CD. That is, AB is 3 times longer than CD: AB = CD + 3CD = 4CD.

3. Member
Join Date
Oct 2009
Posts
128

## Re: Which one is the equivalent?

Thanks a lot. I am clear about it now.
May you have a happy life in London.

4. ## Re: Which one is the equivalent?

Originally Posted by tianhang
Hi, my dear teachers, I am desperate for your help again.
1. Line AB is four times as long as Line CD.
2. Line AB is four times longer than Line CD.
3. Line AB is three times longer than Line CD.
I am confused about these sentences. Some teachers tell me sentence 2 is the equivalent to sentecnce 1, while others tell me sentence 3 is equivalent to sentence 1. Those who think sentence 3 is the equivalent say the second sentence means "Line AB is five times as long as Line CD".
Which one is the equivalent to sentence 1? You please give a detailed answer. A world of thanks to you!
Nice punctuation! You are a very good student.

Yes, the above post is right. Some teachers do say what you mentioned, and they're wrong.

5. Member
Join Date
Oct 2009
Posts
128

## Re: Which one is the equivalent?

You can't imagine how happy I am to hear your praise. A lot of thanks to you. Your help and your praise are what I will cherish in all my life. Wish you happy every day!

#### Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•