Nado, what is the first question we always ask you?
What is YOUR choice?
(However, I can see two possible answers to this. I'll be interested to see whether people agree that two of them can work, even though one is more natural to me.)
Other
Results 1 to 7 of 7
Thread: choose? 8
-
Member
- Join Date: Feb 2010
- Posts: 312
#1 15-Jun-2010, 16:34choose? 8
I--------to spend the summer holiday in Alexandria when my sister suddenly fell ill.
a) had been planning b) have been planning
c) had planned d) have planned
It is a question from my test.
-
-
Moderator
Other
- Join Date: Mar 2007
- Posts: 19,050
#2 15-Jun-2010, 16:44Re: choose? 8
I'm not a teacher, but I write for a living. Please don't ask me about 2nd conditionals, but I'm a safe bet for what reads well in (American) English.
-
Member
Other
- Join Date: Feb 2010
- Posts: 312
#3 15-Jun-2010, 16:52Re: choose? 8
sure I remember . My answer was had been planning. But I don't have a reason.
Sorry it was a silly exam.
-
Newbie
English Teacher
- Join Date: Jun 2010
- Posts: 16
#4 15-Jun-2010, 16:57Re: choose? 8
(Now that Nado has answered)
Yes Barb I agree: A and C are both possible with A being the most frequently used. I hope they didn't mark C as wrong though.
-
Moderator
Other
- Join Date: Mar 2007
- Posts: 19,050
#5 15-Jun-2010, 16:58Re: choose? 8
What is the order of events? Is the planning still going on? If the answer to the second one is yes, then you want a form with "have." If the answer to the second is no, you want a form with "had."
I'm not a teacher, but I write for a living. Please don't ask me about 2nd conditionals, but I'm a safe bet for what reads well in (American) English.
-
Member
Other
- Join Date: Feb 2010
- Posts: 312
#6 15-Jun-2010, 17:06Re: choose? 8
thank you so much my good teachers.
-
VIP Member
Academic
- Join Date: Jun 2008
- Posts: 25,676
#7 16-Jun-2010, 07:24Re: choose? 8
I'd mark C wrong - if only because A is obviously a better choice, and that's the premise of multichoice exams.
Originally Posted by EnglishMuffin
In any case, C doesn't work for me.
It would be alright as "I had planned to spend the summer holiday in Alexandria but my sister suddenly fell ill." or maybe, "I had already planned to spend the summer holiday in Alexandria when my sister suddenly fell ill."
But the exact wording really requires A. It's a tense sequence test: An action in the past perfect continuous is interrupted by an event expressed in the simple past.
