Parser
Is that a polite way of saying something is not correct? :-D
Put it this way, I would normally prefer to say 'I choose to do something' too but I would not rule out the possibility of 'choose' taking on a gerund like what we said about 'welcome'.
How about this example:
I love to sing so I choose singing as my career.
I love to dance so I choose dancing as my career.
***** NOT A TEACHER *****
Hello, Tedtmc.
(1) When I said that it did not sound horrible, I really meant it. It does
not sound horrible -- at least, to me. But the rules say it is not "correct."
(2) Hopefully, the in-house language experts will give you a professional
answer, but I am happy to comment on your question.
(a) I may be wrong, but I believe there is a big difference between
I choose going to the pub
and
I choose singing.
With 100% respect, I believe that the -ing may be the problem. As I tried
earlier to explain, a gerund still has verb qualities. In fact, another poster
also mentioned this matter in an excellent post.
In "I choose going to the pub," you are using a real gerund, because you
say " to the pub," which is a prepositional phrase that modifies the verb
"going." And the experts tell us that we may not use a gerund after verb
"choose."
In "I choose singing as my career," you are using an -ing word only
as a noun. In other words, that sentence really means:
I choose [the profession of] singing as my career.
I know that I did not explain it very well. Maybe one of the teachers
will help me.
***** Thank you *****
P.S. I thought that you would like to know that Mesdames Celce-Murcia
and Larsen-Freeman based their view on work done by one Professor
Bolinger. It seems that the good professor studied many verbs and he
discovered that OFTEN (NOT always) a verb took only the infinitive if it
expresses something "hypothetical, future, unfulfilled." The authors
specified such verbs as: want/expect/hope/decide/refuse/plan/ -- and
our favorite: CHOOSE. They did not list the many other verbs that also
take only the infinitive.