***Neither a teacher nor a native speaker.***
It sounds strange to me.
Firstly you changed the whole sentence, but they only give you the hint "to play"?
Secondly the main sentence contains the word "should", not "has to".
Without knowing the exact task, I would simply say:
Amina should pay more income tax.
If you think that you're sentence matches the task, you can go for this one:
Amina has to pay more tax (than she does).
I wouldn't mention pay twice.
I'm awaiting other replies.