I have a question. Yesterday I made a quiz for my English students.
In the quiz, I wrote the following sentence:
"She grew up on a ranch."
When I was grading the quiz, I found a comment made by one of my students, which said: "it is IN, instead of ON" (She grew up IN a ranch).
I've been searching, and I can't seem to find an answer for this. I googled it, and in most cases, they use ON a ranch for that kind of sentence, but for some other cases, they use IN. So I don't know the difference between them.
I hope you can answer me, so I can give a good explanation to my student when she asks me why is it ON, not IN.
Thanks for your reply
I know it's ON a ranch, but do you know WHY? I mean, why is it ON a ranch instead of IN a ranch? Is there a reason?
My only suggestion is that it's not physically possible to live "in" a ranch. It's a vast area of land, incorporating various buildings and fields and animals etc.
You live in a house/flat/palace/mansion/hovel - these are all single buildings that you physically live inside.
But you live on a farm/ranch/housing estate/council estate - these are all areas which have more than one building. You can't physically be inside any of them.
Prepositions are difficult and there are no rules. The student will have to learn them through usage. We say "IN the car," and "ON the bus, train, etc."
Thanks a lot, everyone!!
This was very helpful :)