ostap77
Key Member
- Joined
- Sep 9, 2010
- Member Type
- Student or Learner
- Native Language
- Ukrainian
- Home Country
- Ukraine
- Current Location
- Ukraine
1) "John left for Sweden. What was he doing before he went to Sweden? He had been getting ready for the conference."(My version.I kind of simplified it)
OR
2)"John has left for Sweden. What had he been doing before he went to Sweden? He had been getting ready for the conference."(Original text)
When there is no time indication I would use Past Simple instead of Present Perefect "John left for Sweden". Am I right? When the second speaker asked the first one "What was he doing before......" he wanted to know in general.
When the first one replied "He had been...." he specified that John did a huge amount work getting ready for the conference.
OR
2)"John has left for Sweden. What had he been doing before he went to Sweden? He had been getting ready for the conference."(Original text)
When there is no time indication I would use Past Simple instead of Present Perefect "John left for Sweden". Am I right? When the second speaker asked the first one "What was he doing before......" he wanted to know in general.
When the first one replied "He had been...." he specified that John did a huge amount work getting ready for the conference.